Nath Kicked Out Of Voces Event
In interview with Urban Milwaukee, Nath gives her version of events.
Purnima Nath.
Purnima Nath, a candidate for Milwaukee County executive, went to Voces De La Frontera’s Annual Assembly Saturday, and left being escorted out by security.
The news was first reported by the Hispanic News Network (HNN), saying Nath went to the event, and in a room full of teenagers, was chanting and ranting about “illegals.” HNN released a video, that appears to be taken by Andrea Rodriguez, a candidate for Milwaukee County Supervisory District Four, of Rodriguez and Voces organizer Primitivo Torres escorting Nath out of the event.
In the video, Rodriguez is heard telling Nath that she “literally just insulted everyone in this room… by calling them illegal.” The short video shows an argument between Rodriguez and Nath. Rodriguez is repeating that Nath needs to leave for her statements and Nath repeats that she is an immigrant and “You cannot come to the country and break the law.”
Voces De La Frontera is an advocacy organization that focuses on immigration policy and workers rights. The event was held by their political arm, Voces De La Frontera Action. Asked why she attended their event, Nath said she goes everywhere as a candidate despite anyone’s disagreement with her political views.
In a statement provided to Urban Milwaukee, Voces De La Frontera Action said Nath “verbally attacked multi-racial youth leaders.” The group removed her from the event to “protect the minors and their parents from abusive rhetoric.”
In the statement Christine Neumann-Ortiz said, “Voces de la Frontera Action is appalled that Purnima Nath, a candidate for Milwaukee County Executive, harassed and verbally attacked immigrant youth during an event that was meant to empower young Wisconsinites. We are incredibly proud of our young leaders who, unlike divisive candidates who follow Trump’s lead by provoking hate and division across racial lines, are focused on organizing and unifying Wisconsin, and the country.”
In an interview with Urban Milwaukee, Nath said she did not confront anyone at the event, but came to interact with potential voters. Nath said she was approached by people at the event that argued with her about immigration, not the other way around.
According to the Hispanic News Network, Nath “apparently entered an art session full of Hispanic teens” and chanted about illegals. Nath disputes this, saying the teens approached her. She was simply mingling as all the other candidates at the event were, Nath said, when the teens approached her.
Nath said she did not go there to chant. She said she went alone. Despite their disagreements about immigration policy, she said, “I am still willing to work with all entities even with Voces De La Frontera.”
Nath is the only conservative running for County Executive. In the past she has expressed support for President Donald Trump and made statements questioning the validity of climate change.
This story was updated to include a statement from Voces De La Frontera Action.
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.
More about the 2020 County Exec Race
- 2020 County Exec Race: Nath Kicked Out Of Voces Event - Graham Kilmer - Feb 3rd, 2020
- 2020 County Exec Race: Seven Will Run for County Executive - Graham Kilmer - Jan 7th, 2020
- Crowley Raises Over $53,000 for County Executive Race - County Executive David Crowley - Jan 6th, 2020
- 2020 County Exec Race: Jim Sullivan Will Run For County Executive - Graham Kilmer - Dec 11th, 2019
- Former County Supervisor Steve F. Taylor Decides Against Entering Race for Milwaukee County Executive - Steve F. Taylor - Dec 5th, 2019
- 2020 County Exec Race: Six Now Running for County Executive - Graham Kilmer - Nov 22nd, 2019
- MKE County: Lipscomb Will Run for County Exec - Graham Kilmer - Nov 12th, 2019
- Murphy’s Law: Who Will Run for County Executive? - Bruce Murphy - Oct 22nd, 2019
Read more about 2020 County Exec Race here
Political Contributions Tracker
Displaying political contributions between people mentioned in this story. Learn more.
MKE County
-
J.D. Vance Plays Up Working Class Roots, Populist Politics in RNC Speech
Jul 17th, 2024 by Graham Kilmer
-
Ron Johnson Says Free-Market Principles Could Fix Education
Jul 17th, 2024 by Graham Kilmer
-
RNC Will Cause Some County Services To Be Moved to Wauwatosa
Jul 12th, 2024 by Graham Kilmer
Why doesnt voces allow diversity of thought at their events? Everyone is entitled to their own opinion
I agree with Mr. Cotic. She was invited to the event. She should be free to express her thoughts if asked. Not everyone agrees with Voces’s positions, and if they are trying to protect teens from exposure to different points of view, they are on the wrong track. I doubt she intended to be insulting, and I wonder if HNN was more interested in the scuffle than the truth.
Uh…”diversity” is one thing; insulting people is entirely another. “Free speech” does not mean there are no consequences for stupid or hateful speech.
Further: it’s irrelevant whether Nath “intended to be insulting”: the use of “illegals” as a noun to describe the undocumented is prejudicial on its face. A candidate for public office, whatever her views, ought to know better than to use bigoted language, especially to insult people to their faces.
No where in this article does it say that Nath was invited. However, it was a public forum. The problem is that the events in question occurred during a breakout session with a room full of teenagers. Let me remind you that teenagers are not adults. We know their frontal lobe is not completely developed, resulting in a lack of impulse control. Nath was the adult in the situation and yet she could not seem to keep her cool. I wonder about her ability to deal with the raucous nature of the county executive job if she can not manage teens. Beyond that, Nath assumed because this was a Latinx gathering that the attendees were (1) immigrants and (2) illegal. The vast majority of Latinx in this country are native born US citizens. Many have ancestors that predate most Euro-Americans. In the past, when the US rounded up illegal Latinx immigrants, more than 60% of those deported were native born US citizens. For anyone to assume that a person who speaks Spanish is an illegal immigrant is the definition of racism. One more fact: there are far more illegal immigrants from Europe in this country than from the Americas.
While Nath has a right to her opinions, if she desires to be the county executive of Milwaukee County, she had better treat the citizens with much more respect than she displayed at the Voces De La Frontera Assembly on Saturday. I for one am sick to death of politicians who feel justified in being rude and disrespectful to communities of color.
I agree with mkwagner. Obviously Nath has a right to her opinions, but if she can’t keep her cool at an open event (where other participants also have a right to their opinions), I don’t see how she would have a chance at keeping County proceedings on a productive track.