Elliott Circle Is A Unique Oddity
City’s only full-circle street near 58th and North has pie-shaped lots, oddly numbered addresses.
Of the streets in the city that are called circles, some are ovals, some are open loops, some are no more than squiggles, and only one of them is a true circle – Elliott Circle. Elliott Circle is completely residential because saloons, whorehouses, hotels, barns, and buildings with flat-top roofs were prohibited by the developer, 76-year-old Catherine (“Kitty”) Dousman Elliott.
Kitty Elliott named Elliott Circle, between N. 58th and N. 59th Streets and a block south of North Avenue, in 1918. She was the daughter of George Dousman, who owned a 250-acre farm that became the Washington Heights neighborhood that includes Elliott Circle. Kitty was the widow of a lawyer and judge, Eugene Elliott, who was a champion chess and whist player.
Her father was deeply involved in the development of the city and served in positions in Juneautown, and later in Milwaukee city and county government. He was a rich merchant who owned a large warehouse on the Milwaukee River in the Third Ward, but lost much of his wealth in wheat speculation that left his farm as his only asset. He died there in 1879.
When she was 23 years old, Kitty married Eugene Elliott. He was born in Illinois in 1842 and came to Milwaukee with his family when he was 10 years old. He attended Dartmouth College and served in the Union Army during the Civil War. Ten years after their marriage and a variety of jobs, Elliott started his law career in a private practice.
It was then that he started playing games seriously. He was a founder of the city’s Chess Club and a frequent winner of chess tournaments held during the 1880s, finishing the decade as city champion. The Chess Club’s interest then switched to a card game that was sweeping the country – whist.
Elliott was known nationally in whist circles and was a charter member and “Father of the American Whist League” which was formed in Milwaukee in 1891. In 1900, after two terms as City Attorney, he became a circuit court judge, a position he held for two years before his sudden death, which occurred at the Milwaukee Whist Club while he was playing his favorite game.
Kitty Elliott died five days short of her 101st birthday in 1943 at her daughter’s home. She is buried next to her husband in Forest Home Cemetery.
Because it is circular, the lots in the center of Elliott Circle are pie-shaped, with the wide part facing the street. An alley leads to the middle of the circle, where there is a concrete apron that provides access to the fourteen garages situated on the narrow end of the lots.
It might take a few spins around the one-way circle for the visitor looking for an address, because it doesn’t conform to the normal numbering pattern. Instead of having even numbers on one side of the street and odd numbers on the other side, all the homes on the north side of the circle, on both sides of the street, have even numbers, while those on the south side of the circle, on both sides of the street, have odd numbers. To make matters more confusing, on the east and west arcs of the outer circle, the houses have a different numbering scheme, one which follows that of N. 58th or N. 59th Streets.
Along Elliott Circle
Carl Baehr, a Milwaukee native, is the author of Milwaukee Streets: The Stories Behind their Names, and articles on local history topics. He has done extensive historic research for his upcoming book, Dreams and Disasters: A History of the Irish in Milwaukee. Baehr, a professional genealogist and historical researcher, gives talks on these subjects and on researching Catholic sacramental record.