Ald. Michael Murphy
Press Release

Proposed state law would reduce local control over Milwaukee’s Fire and Police Commission

Statement of Alderman Michael J. Murphy - November 1, 2017

By - Nov 1st, 2017 12:45 pm

A bill proposed by two GOP state lawmakers is an affront to every citizen and taxpayer of our city. Assembly Bill 606 – sponsored by Rep. Janel Brandtjen of Menomonee Falls and Van Wanggaard of Racine –aims to increase state control of the City of Milwaukee’s Fire and Police Commission, injects politics into a non-political body, and adds significant costs to our local taxpayers.

The proposed change would allow non-residents to serve on the commission, meaning residents from Menomonee Falls, Oak Creek, Franklin, and other suburbs would have the ability to make decisions on the City of Milwaukee’s policies and budget, without having a vested interest in the city.

This legislation comes from members who supposedly loathe any intrusion into local control, and in my view it injects political ideology into Milwaukee’s local governance. Ramming political parties into our local governance and oversight bodies goes against home rule and the long held Wisconsin principle of government by informed local control.

I wonder what the citizens of Menomonee Falls or Racine would have to say if state legislators wanted to severely alter the way one of their key municipal boards or commissions operates.

If suburban legislators are given the ability to dictate massive tax increases to city taxpayers via this change in law, I think there’s a phrase for that: Taxation without representation.

The bill would toss out our current law, which allows the fire and police chiefs to suspend employees for up to 30 days before a hearing. Instead, Assembly Bill 606 would force our taxpayers to keep paying the salaries of the officer or firefighter for at least 10 days after a disciplinary recommendation. According to our Intergovernmental Relations Division, paying these fringe-benefits would cost Milwaukee taxpayers about $1 million annually. This ill-conceived legislation would have a dramatic financial impact on the city. Plus, state control on our local police and fire chiefs is unacceptable.

Assembly Bill 606 would also allow political parties and unions to have substantial influence on the commission. First, the City of Milwaukee would be required to pick from a limited list of candidates provided by the police and firefighter unions for two positions. In a change to a century-old core tenet of the Fire and Police Commission to be a non-political body, this bill injects politics into the commission and requires the mayor to select any members affiliated with a party from lists submitted by the “chief officer” of the Republican and Democratic parties. The current law protects our commission from becoming partisan by prohibiting more than three commission members from being in the same political party.

I plan to fight against this bad piece of legislation at every turn and I strongly encourage Milwaukee citizens and taxpayers to do the same.

Mentioned in This Press Release

Recent Press Releases by Ald. Michael Murphy

Let your voice be heard (and help shape history) by taking the survey!

Statement of Alderman Michael J. Murphy and Alderman Cavalier Johnson

Committee sets public hearing for next week on ARPA funding preferences

Statement from Alderman Michael J. Murphy and Alderman Cavalier Johnson

It’s time to re-open City Hall

Statement of Alderman Michael J. Murphy May 10, 2021

One thought on “Proposed state law would reduce local control over Milwaukee’s Fire and Police Commission”

  1. Paul Trotter says:

    The arrogance of state lawmakers is breathtaking. Thank you Mr. Murphy for standing up for Milwaukee. Why do so called local control “conservatives” hate Milwaukee so much? I suspect the majority of residents except fire and police unions will find this extremely intrusive.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us