Jeramey Jannene
City Hall

Black Members Blast Council President

Chevy Johnson won't take on 'status quo and complacency,' says former president Hamilton and six others.

By - Jul 8th, 2020 05:39 pm
Get a daily rundown of the top stories on Urban Milwaukee
Cavalier Johnson and Ashanti Hamilton.

Cavalier Johnson and Ashanti Hamilton.

The controversial election of Cavalier Johnson as Common Council President in April appears to have fractured the 15-member body.

Johnson, who had spent the past year quietly courting votes for the post, was elected by his peers to the position by a single vote.

Now the seven members on the losing side of the vote are blaming Johnson for enabling what they say is the city’s biggest nemesis – status quo and complacency.

Johnson unseated Ashanti Hamilton, who won a controversial election of his own in 2016. Hamilton bowed out days before the 2020 vote, advancing ally Alderwoman Milele A. Coggs for the post, who lost to Johnson after a rather acrimonious council debate.

The three were at the center of another 8-7 vote yesterday, with the council voting to confirm Claire Woodall-Vogg as the head of the Milwaukee Election Commission. After an initial hearing, all cabinet appointments were sent back on June 16th for an additional hearing on racial equity, triggering Woodall-Vogg to send an email removing herself from consideration, and then another a week later jumping back in. In between, she had an email exchange with Coggs, who led the movement to send all of the appointments back.

“Yesterday, during the full Common Council meeting, unfortunately change was forced to leave the room and replaced by our city’s biggest nemesis: Status quo and complacency,” wrote Hamilton, Coggs, Russell W. Stamper, II, Khalif Rainey, Nikiya Dodd and Chantia Lewis.

Led by Hamilton the group had sought to have Woodall-Vogg appear for another hearing.

“When the Election Commission executive director candidate withdrew her name from consideration for the position, she showed clearly her unwillingness to answer the question at hand: ‘What will you do to end systemic racism in your respective department?’  She instead felt herself above the process and above having to answer the questions of the alders charged with representing the concerns and calls of the Black and Brown community of this city,” said the seven members, all of whom are Black, in a press release.

In an email to Coggs, Woodall-Vogg said the council was grandstanding.

“We strongly disagree with her, because asking her and any other candidate what they plan to do to end systemic racism within their department is NOT grandstanding. It is indeed doing what the people have asked us to do which is to bring about change in a city that has been deemed the worst place in the country for African Americans to live,” wrote the group.

The group then pivoted to criticizing Johnson, who is also Black.

“That again requires leadership and yesterday by appointing the Election Commission head and circumventing the process for appointments our Common Council President Cavalier Johnson (in a clandestine act in concert with the circumvention) was devoid of that leadership and in turn our African American citizens were robbed of the chance to ask the candidate the question at hand which bears repeating: ‘What will you do to end systemic racism in your respective department?’,” they wrote.

Johnson issued his own statement on Tuesday.

“The 2020 election cycle is already underway. Applications for absentee ballots are in the mail to hundreds of thousands of Milwaukee voters, and in just 35 days our citizens will cast their votes in the fall primary election and 119 days from now, voters across the country will select who will serve as President of the United States. When it comes to elections, there is a typical hyperbolic statement accompanying each cycle that, ‘this is the most important election of our lifetime.’ While all elections are important, only a select few in my lifetime has lived up to that billing. This time though, I feel confident in applying that standard to the upcoming federal election,” he said. “Claire Woodall-Vogg has a passion for ensuring voting access to all Milwaukeeans — no matter their neighborhood or zip code.”

Johnson included a copy of a document Woodall-Vogg sent to all council members alongside her letter saying she wanted back in. The four-page document, entitled Equity, Inclusion, and Voting in the City of Milwaukee, addressed challenges and potential solutions to equity and inclusion for voting.

If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits, all detailed here.

More about the 2020 General Election

Read more about 2020 General Election here

Categories: City Hall, Politics

3 thoughts on “City Hall: Black Members Blast Council President”

  1. lccfccoop2 says:

    Thanks for the reporting – I rely on you for understanding what is going on at City Hall. Really hate that racial politics have taken over. Maybe Barrett should have appointed someone else to replace Neil Albrecht. But ClIaire Woodhull Voge is certainly competent – and competence is so necessary now. Time really is of the essence. I have been a poll worker and it isn’t easy to recruit or train.

    Thanks again for the reporting.

  2. John Heinen says:

    I, too, would appreciate the opportunity to share my thoughts and perspective. As a recently retired Asst. City Attorney who worked at City Hall and the Municipal Bldg. for the past 30 years, I think I have something to contribute. John Heinen 414-335-1274

  3. Mingus says:

    I think too often we see certain members of the Milwaukee City Council who are more interested in posturing and political theater than working to deal with the many problems that face Milwaukee. These members are the ones most often maintaining the status quo by their actions and not moving the City forward. Cavalier Johnson is not afraid to move on policy issues that are needed for the City.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us