Building Info

Alchemist Theatre. Photo by Christopher Hillard.
  • Address:
    2569-2573 S. Kinnickinnic Ave.
  • Taxkey:
    4990768000
  • Status:
  • Assessed Value (Land):
    $45,000
  • Assessed Value (Improvements):
    $609,300
  • Assessed Value (Total):
    $654,300
  • Assesment Year:
    2023
  • Year Built:

Acquired by Scott Genke in February 2019. Redevelopment project in 2020-2021 turned it into a home for Honeypie.

Photos

Show All

Content referencing 2569-2573 S. Kinnickinnic Ave.

Eyes on Milwaukee: Deal Would Fix Leaning Stone Creek Wall
Eyes on Milwaukee

Deal Would Fix Leaning Stone Creek Wall

New tenant could replace Stone Creek Coffee at busy Bay View intersection.

Friday Photos: Bay View Addition Nears Completion
Friday Photos

Bay View Addition Nears Completion

Vacant lot on southside main street is no more.

Friday Photos: New Bay View Project Takes Its Place
Friday Photos

New Bay View Project Takes Its Place

BV+ is an 18-unit, two-story apartment building on Kinnickinnic.

Dining: Belli’s Bistro Moving to Old Honeypie Space
Dining

Belli’s Bistro Moving to Old Honeypie Space

Two restaurants moving in Bay View, creating space for a third.

Friday Photos: BV+ Rises on Kinnickinnic Ave.
Friday Photos

BV+ Rises on Kinnickinnic Ave.

Infill project will create 18 units of housing on Bay View's main street.

Eyes on Milwaukee: Renderings Released for New Bay View Building
Eyes on Milwaukee

Renderings Released for New Bay View Building

Two-story BV+ will replace vacant lot on S. Kinnickinnic Ave.

Plats and Parcels: Work Starts on Bay View Complex
Plats and Parcels

Work Starts on Bay View Complex

BV+ building will add 18 apartments, commercial space to Bay View's main street.

Eyes on Milwaukee: April Start for Bay View Apartments
Eyes on Milwaukee

April Start for Bay View Apartments

Developer Scott Genke files for permits to build an 18-unit, two-story building on KK.

Dining: Honeypie Moving to Former Alchemist Theatre Space
Dining

Honeypie Moving to Former Alchemist Theatre Space

Popular Bay View restaurant will move a few blocks north next spring.

Eyes on Milwaukee: Genke Buys Alchemist Theatre Building
Eyes on Milwaukee

Genke Buys Alchemist Theatre Building

SG Property Development will preserve, restore 1927 building on Bay View's main street.

The Alchemist Theatre Has Closed

The Alchemist Theatre Has Closed

Theater's 12-year run comes to an end.

Milwaukee Architecture: A City of Theaters
Milwaukee Architecture

A City of Theaters

Since the 19th century’s German language playhouses, the city has built and renovated countless facilities for theater.

Building data on this page, including assessment information, was last updated on April 5, 2024

See something wrong? Want to report an issue? Contact us.