‘Come From Away’ Becomes Milwaukee Reps All-Time Best-Selling Show, Surpassing ‘A Christmas Carol’

December 1, 2025 [Milwaukee, WI] – Come From Away, the Tony Award-winning musical and inaugural production in Milwaukee Rep’s new Associated Bank Theater Center, has now become the all-time best-selling show in Milwaukee Rep history, surpassing even the beloved holiday tradition A Christmas Carol.

With over $1.55 million in ticket sales, Come From Away has broken the record previously held by the 2016 production of A Christmas Carol which grossed $1,536,136. This achievement comes just weeks after the production shattered the Rep’s mainstage record held by the 2019 West Side Story, underscoring the extraordinary demand and audience enthusiasm for this uplifting musical.

“Surpassing A Christmas Carol as our all-time best-selling production is a remarkable milestone,” said Chad Bauman, Ellen & Joe Checota Executive Director. “It speaks not only to the power of Come From Away’s story of kindness and community, but also to the excitement surrounding Milwaukee Rep’s new Associated Bank Theater Center. This is a moment of pride for our organization and for Milwaukee audiences who have embraced this show so wholeheartedly.”

Directed by Artistic Director Mark Clements, Come From Away runs now through December 14, 2025, in the newly renovated Ellen & Joe Checota Powerhouse Theater. The production kicks off Milwaukee Rep’s 2025/26 inaugural season in the $80 million Associated Bank Theater Center, one of the largest theatrical complexes to open in the last decade.

Come From Away tells the remarkable true story of nearly 7,000 airline passengers from around the world who were grounded in the small Canadian town of Gander in the wake of 9/11. Featuring a dynamic score and spirited performances, the musical has been hailed as an exhilarating celebration of humanity, resilience, and connection.

The cast for Come From Away features many Milwaukee Rep stand out performers including Tony Award-winner Karen Ziemba (Prelude to a Kiss) as Diane, Grace Bobber (The Last Five Years) as Janice, Michael Doherty (The Nerd) as Oz, Kelley Faulkner (Cabaret, Always…Patsy Cline) as Beverley/Annette, Gavin Gregory (Ragtime) as Bob, Richard Ruiz Henry (Guys and Dolls) as Claude, Steven Koehler (Guys on Ice) as Nick/Doug and Megan Loomis (The Craic, Run Bambi Run) as Bonnie. Alongside them are new to Milwaukee Rep cast members Dayna Jarae Dantzler (Waitress, Broadway) as Hannah, Joy Hermalyn (Caroline or Change, Broadway) as Beaulah, Adam Rennie (Rocky Horror Picture Show, Australian tour) as Kevin T/Garth, and Levin Valayil (Elaborate Entrance of Chad Deity, Next Act) as Kevin J/Ali. The band includes Glen Asch, Olivia Dobbs, Bob Monogle, Patrick Morrow, Michael Ritter, Vidar Skrede Paule Westfahl and Ben Yats.

The creative team for Come From Away includes many familiar faces who have helped create Milwaukee Rep standouts Titanic The Musical and Run Bambi Run including music director Dan Kazemi, choreographer Jenn Rose, set designer Todd Edward Ivins, costume designer Theresa Ham, lighting designer Jason Fassl, sound designer Cricket Myers, projection designer Mike Tutaj, voice and dialect coach Jill Walmsley-Zager, casting director Jonathan Hetler, and stage manager Mark Johnson.

The production is presented by David Kundert, Corporate Sponsor PNC Bank, Executive Producers Cheryl and Bill Guc, Sandy and Bill Haack, Susan and Howard Hopwood, and Maureen McCabe.

To purchase tickets to Come From Away, visit www.MilwaukeeRep.com, call the Ticket Office at 414-224-9490, or stop by in person at 108 E Wells Street in downtown Milwaukee.

For more information, please visit www.MilwaukeeRep.com

NOTE: This press release was submitted to Urban Milwaukee and was not written by an Urban Milwaukee writer. While it is believed to be reliable, Urban Milwaukee does not guarantee its accuracy or completeness.