The Contrarian

Journal Sentinel Censors Voucher Test Scores?

All the news about public school test scores, very little about voucher students.

By - Sep 19th, 2019 11:37 am
Get a daily rundown of the top stories on Urban Milwaukee
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Headquarters

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Headquarters

The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel continues to maintain a firewall between its readers and positive news from the state Department of Public Instruction about voucher students.

When it released statewide test results last week, the DPI initially withheld data on students attending private schools under the state’s three parental choice programs.  The state’s bureaucrats achieved their goal: the release — a day later — of positive comparative results for voucher students was ignored.

On Sunday Journal Sentinel education columnist Alan Borsuk’s weekly column focused on the state test results. Omitted was any mention of the fact that DPI data showed voucher students outperforming traditional public school students. Given Borsuk’s many previous columns about private schools in the choice programs, this glaring omission is egregious.

On Monday U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos visited Milwaukee’s St. Marcus Lutheran School. The new positive results, a trend in recent years, were an obvious point of discussion during a roundtable discussion that featured DeVos. Yet Monday afternoon’s online story by the Journal Sentinel’s education reporter excluded this information. (Her story did provide space for a number of children — disguised in adult costumes — who heckled DeVos in front of St. Marcus.)

Here’s a recap of the information the Journal Sentinel has withheld from its readers.

  • Depending on the type of administered test, there are 30 different ways to compare public and voucher data. Voucher students out-performed low-income public students on 29 of 30 measures. Even more notable, voucher students out-performed public students in general on 24 of 30 measures. (See the summary from School Choice Wisconsin.)
  • According to the DPI, public schools spend $13,505 per pupil.
  • Per DPI, per-pupil voucher support for elementary and middle school students is $7,754 and, for high school students, is $8,400.

As a Journal Sentinel digital subscriber, I receive periodic homilies from Editor George Stanley. He dons the armor of a gallant journalist to explain the importance (which I don’t deny) of solid local journalism. Yet the paper that should be a go-to national source for information about school choice elects to boycott the issue.

3 thoughts on “The Contrarian: Journal Sentinel Censors Voucher Test Scores?”

  1. sbaldwin001 says:

    The recap information is startling. Would someone please expand on it with more detail?

  2. Edward Susterich says:

    George Mitchell stated, “… DPI data showed voucher students outperforming traditional public school students….”

    I did not find DPI data substantiating your assertion.

    Anyone can cherry pick the data and make a desired conclusion. How about showing the data that demonstrates your statement– provide all the numbers. If you can’t do so– your contrarian position is flawed and lacks credability.

  3. Barbara Richards says:

    When you defund public education, destroy teacher’s unions – and attack their professionalism; when you have private schools that go to the big funders in town and get $$$$ to air-condition their schools with a total redo of the building — YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR! It costs less for vocher schools? Are salaries and benefits for staff comparable to the public school sector? Do they have the same level of special ed service?
    Leveling the the free public school system is not leveling the playing field. My taxes go to support the privatization of public education. No NO No! Privatization and attacking labor are two main tenets of the three parts of the Shock Doctrine of the Chicago school of economics that has brought countries ( Chile, Brazil, Russia, Canada…)that were positive for low and moderate income persons to the great gap of the the 1%. Corporatization of the global economy is the new “World Sovereignty”. It not only CAN happen here — this is its birth place. Politicians on the right supporting the shock doctrine want to be on the gravy train for campaign $$

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us