Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service

How Alan Goodman Baked a New Business

Launched in 2018, A Goodman’s Desserts sells cookies, bread pudding, cakes and more.

In 2019, Alan Goodman won the Rev-Up MKE pitch competition. Photo by Ana Martinez-Ortiz/NNS

A few years ago, Alan Goodman attended a cookout at a friend’s house. He brought some bread pudding – a specialty of his – for dessert.

Dr. Bruce Hamilton, the party’s host and his friend, pulled him aside during.

“You should be selling this,” Goodman recalled Hamilton telling him. At the time, Goodman worked in the corporate world, but Hamilton’s words and seeing the other guests enjoy his dessert inspired Goodman to do just that.

In October 2018, Goodman launched his business, A Goodman’s Desserts, which features cookies, bread pudding, cakes and other baked goods.

From punishment to reward

Goodman’s first foray into the world of baking started when his parents caught him playing basketball instead of studying at the library. As his punishment, Goodman cooked and baked alongside his mother.

“After I started doing it, I enjoyed it, and I became the family baker,” he said.

Before launching his own business, Goodman researched what it would take to be an entrepreneur and spoke with other entrepreneurs.

“The entrepreneur community in Milwaukee, particularly the young African American community, were an inspiration,” he said.

He reflected on how his corporate skills could help him as an entrepreneur, what he could produce on a mass scale and what the market needs were. In doing so, Goodman landed on cookies – since they are easier to package and store – and bread pudding, which is also easy to store and an uncommon dessert in the Midwest.

Goodman sold some stock he had for his seed money. He then connected with Caitlin Cullen, the former owner of Tandem, about using the restaurant’s commercial kitchen.

He walked into the restaurant as a customer, Cullen said, and one day he brought his bread pudding and asked if he could make his baked goods here. The answer was yes.

Goodman is a personable and cool guy, Cullen said, he brings his humanity into his business with his honesty and vulnerability.

“He’s always been someone I’ve been rooting for,” she said. “Seeing him continuously succeed is really awesome.”

Elmer Moore, the executive director of Scale Up Milwaukee, an initiative that works with and supports local entrepreneurs, met Goodman a few years ago after joining the Kappa Alpha Psi Fraternity Milwaukee alumni chapter. Goodman also participated in Scale Up’s SPARC growth-training program.

Goodman was as much a resource to his peers in the SPARC program as he was a student, Moore said, adding that Goodman’s interest and desire to continue learning are important for anyone but especially entrepreneurs.

“What I like and admire about him are also the parts that make him a good businessperson,” Moore said, noting that he’s unquestionably thoughtful, focuses on serving people and is detail-oriented.

‘Being nimble-minded’

Goodman learned early on to decide what he wanted to do and what he didn’t want to do. For example, most bakers aspire to be brick-and-mortar, but Goodman decided it wasn’t for him.

“My approach is to break something and rebuild it,” he said. “I want to be able to change something on the fly.”

Entrepreneurs have to do what’s best for them, Goodman said, and their choices may not always follow the general model.

“It’s about being nimble-minded and not getting stuck in one direction” he said. “You’re able to shift. You’re the captain of the ship; you want a 360 view of your business.”

In addition to his business, Goodman is an instructor of quality engineering and technology at Milwaukee Area Technical College, and he’s looking into starting a webinar series. It’s smart to have multiple sources of income, he said.

‘Your business is you’

His advice to other budding entrepreneurs is to learn how to pitch.

“Your business is you,” he said. “Being able to communicate that effectively is important.”

His second piece of advice is to not compare your business to the success of others. Success looks different for everyone, he said, and every business model is different. For some it’s a side hustle, for others it’s their main hustle, and for others it’s their retirement plan.

Goodman’s success is in part due to his relationships.

“Relationships are based on how you treat people,” Goodman said. “And I’ve always been raised to treat people well.”

Doors that may not be open to him directly are open to others who can vouch for him, he said. As such, it’s important to him that his businesses give back.

“You should want to do that because people have helped you,” he said. “It’s important for a business to give back. Whatever you choose, be sincere.”

Another key to his success is his confidence to take big swings with his business. It’s why he’s applied to and won local and national contests such as Rev-Up MKE; met Daymond John from “Shark Tank”; and connected with Peter Feigin, the president of the Milwaukee Bucks and Fiserv Forum.

Goodman’s conversation with Feigin led to A Goodman’s Desserts being served at Fiserv Forum during the NBA playoff games and finals.

“Stepping out of my comfort zone with my business is probably the thing I’m most proud of,” Goodman said. “The worst someone can say is ‘no,’ and that’s fine. But it’s not going to happen if you don’t ask.”

This story was originally published by Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service, where you can find other stories reporting on fifteen city neighborhoods in Milwaukee.

If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits, all detailed here.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us