Matt Rothschild
Op Ed

Republican COVID Callousness

Legislators wrong to criticize inmates getting the vaccine when prison infection rates are so high.

By - Feb 4th, 2021 09:42 am
Van Wanggaard. Photo from the State of Wisconsin Blue Book 2015-16.

Van Wanggaard. Photo from the State of Wisconsin Blue Book 2015-16.

Amid the outcry over the insanity of Republican legislators trying to overturn Gov. Tony Evers’s mask mandate, a particularly outrageous display of Republican COVID callousness hasn’t received the attention it deserves.

And that’s the GOP’s effort to block inmates from getting immunizations ahead of the general population in Wisconsin.

Never mind that the COVID outbreak has hit jails and prisons in Wisconsin at astonishing high rates, with slightly more than 50% of all inmates in Wisconsin correctional facilities coming down with the virus.

As of Jan. 29, there have been 10,782 positive tests in Wisconsin prisons, which have 19,858 inmates. There have been 25 COVID-related deaths and currently 908 prisoners are in quarantine and 45 are in isolation, according to the Department of Corrections website.

Never mind that CDC guidelines recommend that inmates get vaccinated at the same time as guards, while the Republicans in Wisconsin oppose this.

“Jurisdictions are encouraged to vaccinate staff and incarcerated/detained persons of correctional or detention facilities at the same time because of their shared increased risk of disease,” says the CDC on its website (and the bold letters are its own). “Outbreaks in correctional and detention facilities are often difficult to control given the inability to physically distance, limited space for isolation or quarantine, and limited testing and personal protective equipment resources.”

But the Republicans want inmates to get in line just like everyone else in their age group, even though people in other confined facilities, such as nursing homes, can get vaccinated now.

Leave it to State Sen. Van Wanggaard (R-Racine) to demagogue on this issue.

“A healthy 30-year-old three-time murderer would be entitled to receive a vaccine before other at-risk individuals,” Wanggaard told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. “A 25-year-old who raped a 60-year-old asthmatic cancer survivor would be entitled to receive the vaccine before his victim. This is not only unwise, it’s unconscionable.”

In addition to complaints from Assembly Speaker Robin Vos and Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce on vaccinating prisoners, another critic was the new Assembly co-chair of the Joint Finance Committee, Rep. Mark Born (R-Beaver Dam).

“Elderly Wisconsinites have been locked in their homes for the last year waiting and waiting for a vaccine. Instead, the committee that advises Gov. Tony Evers and DHS are recommending to vaccinate Wisconsin prisoners instead?” he stated on Twitter.

But the cancer survivor can quarantine at home, or double mask, or avoid crowds, and minimize the risk of infection. The inmates cannot. And inmates, by the way, were not sentenced to COVID.

DHS Deputy Secretary Julie Willems Van Dijk spelled out the “very rational premise” for its decision, and that is to vaccinate those “who are at greatest risk for spread of the disease and sequelae of the disease and greatest risk of exposure.”

She added: “The other thing that’s really important to remember is that outbreaks in a prison have an effect on the community as well. It’s not like it’s contained within a prison when inmates become ill from this illness they spread it to the people who work in the prison, and the people who work in the prison go out into the community and spread it to others.”

So, like most demagoguery, the Republican demagoguery on this issue is dangerous.

Even before the Republicans promoted this bill, I thought inmates in Wisconsin who got infected with COVID would have a good chance of succeeding in court under the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, and Article 1, Section 6, of the Wisconsin Constitution, prohibiting cruel and unusual punishment.

Now if this bill became law, inmates would have an even greater chance of success.

And if Republicans will not be moved by basic human decency, maybe they will be moved by the liability they are exposing all of us to as Wisconsin taxpayers.

Matt Rothschild is the executive director of the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign.

If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits, all detailed here.

3 thoughts on “Op Ed: Republican COVID Callousness”

  1. frank a schneiger says:

    As a former director of health services for of one of the nation’s largest prison systems, let me reinforce Matt Rothschild’s remarks on several levels. On the most basic level, those who are incarcerated, whatever they may have done, are fellow human beings. Also God’s children if you are a spiritual person. In this instance, they are different from the rest of us in having no alternative to the system that has incarcerated them for protecting their health. And, as Senators Wanggaard’s, Vos’ and other’s statements and actions repeatedly demonstrate, it’s not possible to dehumanize others without dehumanizing yourself, one of the many sad consequences of the process of “otherization” that is far down the road in Wisconsin and elsewhere.

    On the second level, it is essential to understand that, as total institutions, prisons and jails are basically Petri dishes for the spread of disease. People, many with pre-existing health conditions, are forced to live in close quarters in poorly ventilated buildings. It is that simple.

    Then, a point that the Republican forces of law and order conveniently ignore when it is possible to score some cheap political points. In addition to the women, men and adolescents incarcerated in these institutions, there are staff members who, at the end of their tours, go home to their families and the communities in which they live. Like the packing house workers, they are at increased risk by virtue of their work, and also have the potential to be super-spreaders of the corona virus. In Vos/Wanggard-land, are they also surplus populations who don’t really count?

    There are numerous points in the current crisis where basic humanity, public health and a sound strategy are in complete alignment. This is just one of them. And it will be interesting, when all of this is in the rear-view mirror, for the kids of Vos, Wanggaard, their Republican colleagues and many of their hard-core constituents to ask, “So daddy, what did you do to help in the pandemic?”

  2. GodzillakingMKE says:

    I’ll say it Simply Republicans are cruel heartless greedy, they think they’re entightled to power and believe they have the right to decide who lives and dies.

  3. weitenma83 says:

    There is also money at stake here. If an inmate gets so sick that they have to be hospitalized, who pays the bill? We do, the taxpayers. It is better to vaccinate these people right away just as a practical matter. My younger daughter works at a hospital in San Francisco. At one point they had 35 prisoners from San Quentin in their hospital being treated for COVID. They don’t get San Quentin prisoners regularly, so imagine how many others were in hospitals elsewhere. Of course Repubs would say that they shouldn’t get any hospital care, just let them die.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us