Why Should Court End Mask Mandate, Judge Asks
Legislature has power to end Evers mandate, he notes, why should court usurp that right?
A judge hearing the lawsuit over Wisconsin’s statewide mask mandate repeatedly asked a lawyer for conservatives at a Monday hearing why he should block the mandate when the Legislature has decided not to.
The lawsuit, which was brought by the conservative Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty (WILL) on behalf of three Wisconsin residents, argues that Democratic Gov. Tony Evers overstepped his authority when he issued and later extended a statewide mask mandate this year.
Evers has used the powers to declare three public health emergencies this year. The first came on March 12, at the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic. The second, on July 30, led to the first mask mandate and came as COVID-19 cases were beginning to climb. And the third, on Sept. 22, extended the mask mandate as COVID-19 cases were surging on University of Wisconsin campuses.
WILL argued that because a governor’s public health emergency declaration “shall not exceed 60 days” unless it’s extended by the Legislature, Evers’ second and third public health declarations were invalid, and the court should strike them down.
“The pandemic that we had in July and September is the same one we had in March,” said WILL attorney Anthony LoCoco. “It’s the same essential public health problem: The spread of a novel virus.”
LoCoco said that for many people, wearing a mask may seem simple, smart and courteous, and they may not care that the government had ordered them to wear masks.
“But my clients do care,” LoCoco said. “They are aggrieved by this invasion of their liberty.”
But just as state lawmakers have the power to extend a governor’s emergency, they also have the power to revoke it.
“They’re asking the third branch of government — the judiciary — to step in and exercise a power that the Legislature reserved to itself,” said Judge Waterman. “The court is being asked to do that when the Legislature has apparently chosen for one reason or another not to act.”
Evers’ attorney, Assistant Attorney General Colin Hector, stressed that the nature of the COVID-19 pandemic now was worsening, making this a different emergency than the ones the state had dealt with at other points this year.
“The data here is screaming out that unfortunately, Wisconsin right now is in a very different and much worse situation than it has been,” Hector said.
Wisconsin’s recent COVID-19 numbers have been among the worst in the nation with a seven-day average of nearly 2,400 positive daily cases. In mid-May, that number was less than 300. The number of people hospitalized for COVID-19 also hit an all-time high of 782 Monday.
Hector also stressed that the law Evers used to declare an emergency gave the Legislature the express power to end it.
“They have to take a political act,” Hector said. “It can’t possibly be the case that they can have the courts make that decision for them.”
Democrats have argued that Republicans won’t vote to rescind the mask mandate because it’s popular. In early August, 69 percent of registered voters surveyed by Marquette University favored a mask mandate compared to 29 percent who opposed it.
While the case is in his courtroom for now, the Wisconsin Supreme Court will likely have the final say on the mask mandate and the governor’s powers. What happens there is not yet clear.
While the court struck down “Safer at Home” in May, it had a 5-2 conservative majority at the time, a margin that has since been trimmed to 4-3.
That would put the focus squarely on conservative Justice Brian Hagedorn, who joined the court’s liberals in siding with the Evers administration earlier this year.
Judge Questions Need For Court To Rule On Mask Mandate was originally published by Wisconsin Public Radio.
- DHS Updates COVID-19 Illness After Vaccination Page to Include Data by Booster Dose Status - Wisconsin Department of Health Services - May 26th, 2022
- WI Health Department Urges Booster Shots for Ages 5 to 11 - Erik Gunn - May 24th, 2022
- DHS Recommends COVID-19 Vaccine Booster Doses to Everyone 5 and Older - Wisconsin Department of Health Services - May 23rd, 2022
- MKE County: COVID-19 Cases Rising Again - Graham Kilmer - May 20th, 2022
- City of Milwaukee Weekly COVID-19 Update - Wisconsin Department of Health Services - May 20th, 2022
- City of Milwaukee Mask Advisory - City of Milwaukee Health Department - May 20th, 2022
- State’s COVID-19 Cases Up 66% in May - Erik Gunn - May 17th, 2022
- City of Milwaukee Weekly COVID-19 Update - City of Milwaukee Health Department - May 13th, 2022
- DHS Announces the Moving Forward Together Grant Program to Support Health Equity Efforts in COVID-19 Vaccinations - Wisconsin Department of Health Services - May 12th, 2022
- City of Milwaukee Weekly COVID-19 Update - City of Milwaukee Health Department - May 6th, 2022
Read more about Coronavirus Pandemic here
- Court Watch: Why Court Voided Evers Emergency Order - Gretchen Schuldt - Apr 5th, 2021
- Statement by Heartland Institute Director Jeré Fabick on WI Supreme Court Victory Against Gov. Tony Evers - Heartland Institute - Mar 31st, 2021
- Senator Agard: Statement on Supreme Court Decision - State Sen. Melissa Agard - Mar 31st, 2021
- Wisconsin’s Hyperpartisan Supreme Court is Endangering the Public - Democratic Party of Wisconsin - Mar 31st, 2021
- Wisconsin Supreme Court: Gov. Evers’ Multiple Emergency Declarations Violate Law - Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty - Mar 31st, 2021
- Rep. Hesselbein Statement on Supreme Court Ruling on Emergency Orders - State Rep. Dianne Hesselbein - Mar 31st, 2021
- Statement on Wisconsin Supreme Court Decision - State Sen. Jon Erpenbach - Mar 31st, 2021
- Gov. Evers Releases Statement Regarding Supreme Court Decision - Gov. Tony Evers - Mar 31st, 2021
- Rep. Hintz: Statement on Wisconsin Supreme Court Ruling - State Rep. Gordon Hintz - Mar 31st, 2021
- State Supreme Court Overrules Evers’ Emergency Powers - Laurel White - Mar 31st, 2021
Read more about Statewide Mask Mandate here