Karofsky Easily Defeats Kelly
54-46 margin for liberal candidate in race for Wisconsin Supreme Court.
Dane County Judge Jill Karofsky has won a 10-year term on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, defeating conservative incumbent Justice Daniel Kelly to hand Democrats a victory in the officially nonpartisan election.
According to preliminary results as of 10:40 p.m. Monday, Karofsky led Kelly 54-46 percent. While the results were released Monday, voting took place in-person last Tuesday and by mail over the course of the past month.
Karofsky’s campaign issued a statement declaring victory before the race was even officially called by the Associated Press.
“I want to send a heartfelt thank you to the hundreds of thousands of Wisconsinites who made their voice heard in this unprecedented election,” Karofsky said.”I’m honored to have earned the trust of people across this state who believe in a tough, fair, and independent judiciary and I promise to never forget these principles as their Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice.”
While any race for the court is important — Wisconsin has just seven justices who serve 10-year terms — the contest between Kelly and Karofsky took a distant back seat to the circumstances of the election itself. Despite daily warnings from the state and federal government to stay at home because of COVID-19, Wisconsin forged ahead with in-person voting.
To say that this was an unusual election would be an understatement.
On election day, voters and poll workers covered themselves with face masks, gloves, goggles and plastic aprons in an effort to guard themselves against the spread of the new coronavirus.
Prior to then, more than a million voters requested absentee ballots, shattering records for what might normally be a low-turnout election.
Amidst that surge in absentee voting, multiple lawsuits were filed to try to postpone or delay the election. U.S. District Court Judge William Conley ruled he lacked the power to delay the election, but Conley did give voters until 4 p.m. April 13 to return absentee ballots. In a separate order, Conley banned clerks from releasing any results until that time.
Even before vote totals were announced Monday, a group of Milwaukee-area residents filed a class-action lawsuit seeking a partial or full re-vote of the election. And Karofsky herself was soliciting donations to her legal fund.
While Supreme Court elections races are relatively obscure at the state level, national politicians have staked their claims on Wisconsin’s race. Democrats Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders both endorsed Karofsky. President Donald Trump has campaigned for Kelly, both on Twitter and at a White House coronavirus briefing.
Kelly was appointed to the state Supreme Court by former Republican Gov. Scott Walker in 2016. Prior to joining the court, he worked for years as a lawyer in private practice, including on a case that successfully defended the Republican redistricting plan Walker signed into law nearly a decade ago.
He issued a statement Monday night saying he was grateful to have served on the court.
“Obviously I had hoped my service would continue for another decade, but tonight’s results make clear that God has a different plan for my future,” Kelly said. “I congratulate Judge Karofsky and wish her well as she assumes the responsibilities of this important office.”
Kelly is the first incumbent justice to lose election to the court since Louis Butler, a Democratic appointee who lost his race to Michael Gableman in 2008. Prior to that, no incumbent had lost since 1967.
Even with Karofsky’s win, conservatives still hold a 4-3 majority on the Supreme Court, meaning they’ll control the court during the next round of redistricting unless a justice leaves before the end of their term.
But given their new numbers, liberals will have a chance to flip control of the court during the next scheduled election in 2023.
Jill Karofsky Wins Wisconsin Supreme Court Race, Defeating Conservative Incumbent was originally published by Wisconsin Public Radio.
- Why Don Natzke Couldn’t Vote - Enjoyiana Nururdin - Aug 9th, 2020
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report highlights public health measures taken by the Milwaukee Health and Fire Departments, Department of Administration, Election Commission, and the Wisconsin Department of Health Services - City of Milwaukee Health Department - Aug 4th, 2020
- CDC Says Election Did Not Cause COVID-19 Spike - Erik Gunn - Aug 4th, 2020
- Pandemic Reduced Black Vote, Study Finds - Dee J. Hall - Jun 25th, 2020
- Did April Election Hike COVID-19 Cases? - Alana Watson - May 20th, 2020
- Elections Commission Notes ‘Lessons Learned’ - Henry Redman - May 19th, 2020
- Wisconsin Elections News: WEC Releases Analysis of Absentee Voting in April 7 Spring Election - Wisconsin Elections Commission - May 18th, 2020
- Election’s Impact on County’s COVID-19 Cases Unclear - Jeramey Jannene - May 6th, 2020
- Why State’s Voting By Mail Was Chaotic - Daniel C. Vock - May 4th, 2020
- At Least 40 COVID-19 Cases Tied to Election in Milwaukee - Graham Kilmer - Apr 24th, 2020
Read more about 2020 Spring Primary here