Council Grills Mayor, City Health Staff
Tense meeting with unprecedented scrutiny of mayor and few answers from staff.
The Common Council wasted no time getting their investigation into the Health Department underway. After approving the probe this morning, the entire council held a marathon hearing this afternoon where Mayor Tom Barrett and members of the Health Department answered question after question regarding the city’s lead abatement program. One veteran aldermen said Barrett had never before been questioned at such length during his 13-year tenure as mayor.
The hearing comes after Barrett announced last Friday the resignation of Health Department Commissioner Bevan K. Baker and disclosed three years of errors discovered with lead poisoning notification data.
Council president Ashanti Hamilton began the hearing by stating “We are at a pivotal moment in our city where both thoughtfulness and urgency will have to be given to this lead issue,” before ceding the floor to Barrett.
The mayor laid out the timeline by which his office, and ultimately Barrett himself, became aware of the specific issue with the Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Program. Barrett said he began raising questions after learning the city was not spending federal Department of Housing and Urban Development funds for lead paint abatement at rate expected by HUD, which he learned during routine November and December management meetings the mayor holds with department heads.
At issue are thousands of notifications required to go out to families of children that test positive for elevated levels of lead in their blood. Of the approximately 2,000 notifications required for 2017, Barrett said “I’m looking at a sheet that says notifications were made to 1,500 people, and naturally my response was well what about the other 500 people. The response that I got was well ‘we don’t know.'”
Baker resigned on Thursday, January 11th and on Friday, January 12th the Mayor held his press conference.
Even if all the letters to families were sent as required, there is no precise documentation of it. “We know at a minimum there is sloppy bookkeeping,” said Barrett.
To remediate the issue, Barrett says the city will now send 8,000 notifications to affected families that may have previously received a notice dating back to 2015. Interm department head Paul Nannis is being charged with ensuring the department has adequate staffing levels to perform follow-up tests.
Having made his case, Barrett and Health Department staff were than hit with questions, lots and lots of questions.
Barrett appeared to answer many to the council’s satisfaction, while questions to the Health Department staff who joined Barrett for this session generated mixed reactions.
Characterizing the responses given by members of the Health Department, Ald. Jim Bohl remarked: “It seems that it’s ‘I don’t know’ on top of ‘I don’t know’ on top of ‘I don’t know.'”
Barrett cautioned that the council should wait to discuss personnel matters until they were able to go into closed session. He noted that an investigation was underway, but that no criminal activity was believed to have taken place.
One thing the council took issue with was perceived sloppy records management by the department, which seemed to be a major cause of problems. The city has been using a paper bookkeeping system and has only recently begun the process of preparing for a transition to computer-based record keeping for the notifications, which are required by the state.
The issue quickly expanded beyond its bookkeeping to the department’s practices.
Numerous council members expressed surprise to learn that when extremely high levels of lead are found the Health Department does a home environmental assessment, but until 2018 only looked for issues with lead paint. The HUD grants that fund such work don’t require or pay for water testing, nor does state statute require this be done.
The Health Department sought an opinion from the City Attorney’s office on whether the city could test the water in homes which could be potentially contaminated by lead laterals, but did not receive a response for a number of months. According to Health Department representatives, the attorney only provided an opinion verbally.
The department then proceeded in late 2017 to update their policy to begin offering voluntary testing of water — when homeowners agree to it — starting in 2018 when they do environmental assessments. Ald. Russell W. Stamper, II and other council members expressed surprise that it was only voluntary.
Saying he would have welcomed a lawsuit on the matter, Hamilton said: “It just seems a ridiculous concern if you have a child with elevated lead levels, if you can’t then test the house.”
Responding to a question from Ald. Robert Donovan about the potential for a U.S. Attorney’s investigation, Barrett said he would welcome the investigation. He said the city intends to work closely with the federal government’s Center for Disease Control to improve practices within the department.
Barrett also said he would be amenable to an audit conducted by an outside party, but would need to see the specific legislation. The audit is being proposed by council members Tony Zielinski, Jose G. Perez and Stamper.
According to Sandra Rotar, since 2015 there has been a significant amount of staff turnover at the department. Rotar is the top ranking member of the department following Baker’s departure.
Department Director of Disease Control and Environmental Health staffer Angela Hagy got into a heated back-and-forth with the council regarding the timeline and contents of a whistleblower email from former employee Benjamin James. Hagy claimed she was acting on James’ concern regarding water testing in advance of him sending his email to the council and mayor on December 28th. She told the council the department had not acted on implementing water testing because it was awaiting an opinion from the city attorney.
Said Donovan, the resident law-and-order member of the council: “I hope to God this investigation tells us who is responsible for this.” Hamilton said the council has identified what division of the department the data breakdown occurred in, but has yet to identify a single source.
The sometimes contentious hearing was more tense because of the behavior of some audience members. Freshwater for Life Action Coalition president Robert Miranda made constant remarks under his breath before storming out of the room midway in the long meeting.
The council spent an hour in closed session after two-and-a-half hours of debate. Barrett described the private discussion as “serious,” while numerous council members declined to discuss the closed-doors meeting.
The council is likely to introduce legislation regarding the city’s health policies in the coming weeks. Hamilton stressed that the council will seek to divide the legal issues from the departmental issues.
The city will also need to find a new Health Commissioner. A national search will be conducted to find Baker’s replacement. Nannis, who held the job before Baker, is back for a period of 120 days and is not seeking the post permanently.
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits, all detailed here.
More about the Lead Service Lines
- Milwaukee’s Young Children Need to Be the Focus - Ald. Mark Borkowski - Sep 24th, 2018
- City Hall: Baker To Testify Before Common Council - Jeramey Jannene - Sep 14th, 2018
- Warning Residents of Lead Dangers - Jenny Whidden - Jul 18th, 2018
- Governor Walker Administration Awards More Than $26 Million for Lead Service Line Replacement in 42 Wisconsin Communities - Gov. Scott Walker - Jul 18th, 2018
- Environmental Review of City of Milwaukee Project for the Safe Drinking Water Loan Program (SDWLP) - Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources - Jul 9th, 2018
- Environmental review of City of Milwaukee project for the Safe Drinking Water Loan Program (SDWLP) - Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources - Jun 26th, 2018
- Common Council approves full lead hazard review for city-owned properties - Ald. Jose Perez - May 8th, 2018
- Legislation mandates lead water lines replacement at child care facilities - Ald. Milele Coggs - Apr 26th, 2018
- Child Care Centers Still Have Lead Pipes - Edgar Mendez - Apr 23rd, 2018
- Legislation looks to local source for water infrastructure needs - Ald. Milele Coggs - Apr 4th, 2018
- ‘10thirtysix ’ to re-ring the alarm bell on milwaukee’s lead crisis - Milwaukee PBS - Mar 27th, 2018
- Chief of Staff Comment on FLAC - Patrick Curley - Mar 22nd, 2018
- Evers Demands Action on Wisconsin’s Drinking Water Crisis - Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Evers - Mar 21st, 2018
- Op Ed: How City Should Solve Lead in Water - Noelle Chesley, Anne Dressel, John Berges, and Helen Meier - Mar 2nd, 2018
- Alderman Bohl: A better strategy is needed in dealing with lead laterals - Ald. Jim Bohl - Feb 26th, 2018
- City Hall: McManus Lays Out Three Priorities for Health Department - Jeramey Jannene - Feb 23rd, 2018
- Governor Walker Signs Leading on Lead Act into Law - Gov. Scott Walker - Feb 21st, 2018
- City Hall: Mayor Allows Interim Health Leader - Jeramey Jannene - Feb 15th, 2018
- City Hall: Will Mayor Confirm Health Commissioner? - Jeramey Jannene - Feb 14th, 2018
- City Hall: HUD Halts City Lead Treatment Program - Jeramey Jannene - Feb 12th, 2018
- From Dr. Patricia McManus: Comments clarified - Common Council President Ashanti Hamilton - Feb 9th, 2018
- Comments by newly appointed interim Health Department commissioner troubling - Ald. Michael Murphy - Feb 9th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Appoints McManus Interim Health Leader - Jeramey Jannene - Feb 6th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Barrett Withdraws Nannis Nomination - Jeramey Jannene - Feb 5th, 2018
- FLAC Calls on Common Council to Confirm Dr. Patricia McManus as Interim Health Commissioner - Freshwater For Life Action Coalition - Feb 3rd, 2018
- Silence is Complicity – If You See Something, Please Say Something - Ald. Milele Coggs - Feb 2nd, 2018
- Gag Order for Health Department Employees Lifted by Mayor - Ald. Bob Donovan - Feb 1st, 2018
- Resolution Aims to Take Down Milwaukee Health Department’s Restrictive Communication Policy - Ald. Tony Zielinski - Feb 1st, 2018
- Common Council Alerts At-Risk Populations of Lead Risks After City of Milwaukee Health Department Fails to Notify Public - Milwaukee Common Council - Jan 31st, 2018
- Key Details Missing from the Mayor’s Account of Lead Testing Crisis - Ald. Khalif Rainey - Jan 31st, 2018
- What We Really Need: Answers - Ald. Russell Stamper, II - Jan 31st, 2018
- The Administration has Lost the Common Council’s Confidence in Addressing the Lead Issue - Ald. Jose Perez - Jan 30th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: City Report Finds Health Dept. Problems - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 30th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Could Reject Interim Health Leader - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 30th, 2018
- Aldermen Ask City Attorney for Legality of Paul Nannis’ position - Milwaukee Common Council - Jan 29th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: $750 Million to Replace Lead Pipes - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 24th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Responds to Lead Crisis - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 23rd, 2018
- Legislation seeks lead service line replacement for city-owned properties - Ald. Bob Bauman - Jan 19th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Grills Mayor, City Health Staff - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 17th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Launches Health Dept. Probe - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 17th, 2018
- Resolution calls for Milwaukee Water to give public lead updates - Ald. Tony Zielinski - Jan 17th, 2018
- Commissioner Baker’s departure leaves us all with many, many questions - Ald. Bob Donovan - Jan 16th, 2018
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Barrett Ousts Bevan Baker Over Lead Fiasco - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 12th, 2018
- Health Department mistakes worsen city’s lead crisis - Ald. Mark Borkowski - Jan 12th, 2018
- Council set to act on Health Department crisis - Milwaukee Common Council - Jan 12th, 2018
- Freshwater For Life Action Coalition (FLAC) to Hold Press Conference After Announcement Of Firing Health Commissioner Bevan Baker - Freshwater For Life Action Coalition - Jan 12th, 2018
- Is City Dragging Feet on Lead Filters? - Jabril Faraj and Elliot Hughes - Jan 3rd, 2018
- Common Council Strengthens Lead Standards - Jabril Faraj - Dec 5th, 2017
- One Step Closer to Tackling Wisconsin’s Lead Crisis - State Sen. Chris Larson - Oct 31st, 2017
- Advocates Push City On Lead Pipes - Jabril Faraj - Oct 25th, 2017
- Lead Poisoning a “Public Health Crisis” - Jabril Faraj - Jul 19th, 2017
- National Water Expert Retracts Criticism of City Health Department - City of Milwaukee Health Department - Jul 14th, 2017
- Governor Walker Announces 35 Municipalities to Receive a Total of $13.8 Million to Remove Lead Service Lines - Gov. Scott Walker - Jun 28th, 2017
- Campaign Cash: WMC Opposes Lead Pipes Bill - Wisconsin Democracy Campaign - Apr 20th, 2017
- Op Ed: State Action Needed on Lead Pipes Problem - Chris Walker - Mar 12th, 2017
- Murphy’s Law: How Milwaukee Handled “Flint” Crisis - Bruce Murphy - Jan 19th, 2017
- Tainted Water: State’s Failures On Lead Pipes - Cara Lombardo and Dee J. Hall - Jan 15th, 2017
- Tainted Water: Lax Rules Expose Kids To Lead-Tainted Water - Cara Lombardo and Dee J. Hall - Dec 19th, 2016
- Tainted Water: DNR Program Replaces Lead Laterals - Cara Lombardo and Dee J. Hall - Dec 19th, 2016
- Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Approves Help For Lead Pipes - Jeramey Jannene - Dec 13th, 2016
- Tainted Water: DNR Delays on Lead Poisoning Issue - Cara Lombardo and Dee J. Hall - Dec 4th, 2016