State Sen. Kathleen Vinehout
Op Ed

Walker’s Budget Makes Schools More Unequal

Old equalized aid formula is broken. Governor makes inequity even worse.

By - Feb 12th, 2017 10:25 am
Rufus King. Photo by Christopher Hillard.

Rufus King. Photo by Christopher Hillard.

“Public education in Wisconsin should provide high quality learning for ALL children no matter who they are or where they live,” Eau Claire School Board President Chris Hambuch-Boyle recently told me.

Chris and education leaders across the state read with interest details of the Governor’s plan for our next state budget. Governor Walker gave money to a number of new initiatives and reaped the praise of some education leaders.

The plan picks and chooses among various proposals advanced over the last few years. Some new programs are funded and some existing programs get more money. The plan is a compromise.

However – as with any political compromise – we should know what is not included and what is not being done.

We fund schools primarily through a school aid formula. Its purpose is to “equalize” resources in school districts across Wisconsin so regardless of where a child lives in the state, the opportunities for learning will be relatively equal.

The equalized aid formula is broken. A number of plans were proposed to fix the formula including ideas I supported. But the Governor’s new plan does nothing to fix the formula.

Rather, most of the new money in the Governor’s plan gives the same dollars to property-rich districts as to property-poor districts.

This is a new direction for our state.

Since 1973, governors have supported sending money for schools through the equalized aid formula. The policy of both parties was to see that every Wisconsin child had the same benefit of equal opportunity for a sound education.

Board President Hambuch-Boyle expressed concerns that the Governor’s plan “Makes the inequity worse. Under the guise of ‘here’s some more money’ he extends the inequity.”

Consequently, children in property-rich schools have a better opportunity than children living in a property-poor district. School districts across state would be better served if the additional dollars recommended by the Governor were distributed through an improved equalized aid formula. Children would be better served if school leaders knew they could count on a steady partnership from the state.

President Hambuch-Boyle and many others across the state are working very hard to re-imagine public education for 21st Century students. Leaders in western Wisconsin encouraged legislators to learn about innovations. During a recent visit to an Eau Claire Middle School, I saw evidence of a new world in our public schools.

What do we want from our education system for our children? We want a place for our children to learn, to develop cognitive and social skills. We need our children to develop character and become responsible citizens. But we also want our children to find their passion and purpose.

Tony Wagner and Ted Dintersmith write in their book, Most Likely to Succeed, that students need to tackle the challenge of how to “leverage your passion and talents to make the world better.”

Most Likely to Succeed is both a book and a documentary. Local education leaders recently invited legislators to view the film and talk about changes in our classrooms. The film explores innovation in education and the possibilities for the 21st century school. After viewing the film and visiting the ARCTIC Zone classroom at Eau Claire’s Northstar Middle School, I am beginning to see the future of education.

“The world no longer cares how much you know, because Google knows everything. What the world cares about – what matters for learning, work and citizenship – is what you can do with what you know,” write Wagner & Dintersmith. Students need to learn in groups by practicing problem solving and navigating group dynamics.

Critical thinking, communication, and collaborative problem solving are skills actively taught and evaluated as part of the school day in pioneering programs. New ways of teaching and learning means many old ways must change. Resources are needed. Funding stability is critical.

Wisconsin schools can innovate. We can provide high quality opportunities for our children that live in Beloit, Black River Falls, Brookfield or Bruce.

To get there, school leaders must be confident they don’t have to worry about deep cuts in the next budget and we must fix the current school funding formula. This commitment is necessary to provide an equal opportunity education to every child.

Sen. Kathleen Vinehout, D-Alma, is a member of the Wisconsin state Senate.

Categories: Education, Op-Ed, Politics

3 thoughts on “Op Ed: Walker’s Budget Makes Schools More Unequal”

  1. Wisconsin Conservative Digest says:

    Since the Educrats claim that we should” INVEST” more money in schools, tell us what this investment will get us?? Will it fix the bad districts that cannot even teach kids to read? Will scores go up instead of down?
    Since 1970 we have increased spending for schools tenfold for half as many kids yet scores are down.

  2. Rita Brunkow says:

    Wisconsin Conservative Digest -Your claims are misleading at best. Please see the National Center for Education Statistics government website. We still have well over 800,000 students in Wisconsin. We had less than 900,000 in 1970. All 50 states had large increases in education costs between 1971 to 1990, likely mostly due to many years of higher inflation in the country in those decades. I have no idea which schools you mean by “bad” schools. Do you mean every school that is not a rich suburban school? There are kids in every school that need special help with reading. We need to give every single kid a fair shot at a good education, no matter where they live. I sure appreciate the fair shot I had and I bet you do too. Walker’s budget is a freeway to unequal educational opportunities.

  3. Rita Brunkow says:

    Wisconsin Conservative Digest, your claims are misleading at best. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, Wisconsin has over 800,000 students now and had over 800,000 in 1970. School funding went up significantly for all states since 1970, mostly in the high inflation decades of 1970’s and 80’s. Wisconsin’s increases were proportional to the other states. What schools do you mean when you say “bad” schools? Any school but mostly white, suburban schools that have more money? You will find kids in EVERY school that need extra help with reading. Wisconsin must offer a fair opportunity for a good education for every student. I am grateful for the fair opportunity I had in school. Aren’t you? Walker’s budget does not offer the same opportunity to all students.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us