Milwaukee Needs Bold Leadership to Solve the Housing Crisis
The severity of the problem must be met with commensurate action and policy
Milwaukee, like most of America, is facing a housing crisis. Rents are soaring, affordable housing is scarce, and our city’s zoning laws are stifling the types of housing that our communities desperately need. What we need now is bold leadership—leaders who are ready to face difficult truths and make hard choices, even in the face of pushback.
Outgoing Ford Foundation President Darren Walker put it best: “We need leaders who manifest a moral capacity to embrace the nuance and complexity to which we’ve become allergic, come what may — to take a stand for progress, even if incremental or imperfect.” That sentiment captures exactly what is required to tackle Milwaukee’s housing crisis: the courage to embrace complexity and move forward with solutions that may not satisfy everyone but will undeniably benefit our city.
The Reality of Our Housing Crisis
The data is clear: allowing more homes types and more choices will help lower housing cost and meet people’s needs. Current zoning restrictions drive up the cost of housing and block the creation of housing types that our community wants. Duplexes, triplexes, and small apartment buildings—forms of housing that have historically provided affordability and stability—are outlawed in large swaths of Milwaukee under today’s zoning rules. This doesn’t just hurt those seeking affordable housing; it perpetuates a system that favors exclusivity over inclusion.
The Consequences of Waiting Too Long
Across the country, cities that delayed updating their zoning codes have seen the unintended consequences of inaction. By the time reforms were enacted, housing inventories were so low and demand so high that prices skyrocketed, and underserved communities bore the brunt of displacement and gentrification. The very harm these cities sought to prevent—pushing people out of their neighborhoods—was made worse by their reluctance to act.
Milwaukee must learn from these cautionary tales. Delaying zoning reform like Growing MKE will only exacerbate our housing crisis, leaving too many families without affordable options and driving prices even higher. Reform is not about putting undue burden on any single neighborhood or dismissing concerns—it’s about acknowledging that the status quo is unsustainable. Without meaningful action to allow more homes, we risk perpetuating the very harm we wish to avoid.
Milwaukee’s leaders have a choice: act now to open up our city to diverse housing options or continue down a path that restricts growth and harms the communities we are trying to protect.
The Call for Bold Leadership
Milwaukee needs leaders who will acknowledge the truth: we have a housing crisis, and zoning reform can help. Leaders who will be bold enough to defend this position, even when it means having difficult conversations. Leaders who understand that progress doesn’t happen without pushback.
Yes, Growing MKE may not be perfect. No solution ever is. But the cost of inaction is too high. It is time for bold leadership to step up and deliver the policies Milwaukee needs to build a more inclusive and prosperous future for everyone.
Montavius Jones, Principal Narvarte Development and Alex Rodriguez of Community First.
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.
More about the Growing MKE proposal
- Op Ed: Milwaukee Needs Bold Leadership to Solve the Housing Crisis - Montavius Jones and Alex Rodriguez - Jan 3rd, 2025
- HUD Launches $100 Million Competitive Home Fund in Milwaukee - Jeramey Jannene - Aug 14th, 2024
- Milwaukee is ahead of the curve when it comes to residential zoning - Ald. Russell Stamper, II - Jul 30th, 2024
- City Hall: Growing MKE Plan Suffers Sudden Growing Pains - Jeramey Jannene - Jul 30th, 2024
- Our voices will NOT be silenced this time – Lessons from MKE’s “GROWTH” of the past - Ald. Russell Stamper, II - Jul 29th, 2024
- First Key Vote On Zoning Overhaul Scheduled For Monday - Jeramey Jannene - Jul 26th, 2024
- Op-Ed: Unlocking Milwaukee’s Potential Through Smart Zoning Reform - Ariam Kesete - Jul 5th, 2024
- Milwaukee Receives $2.1M From HUD For Growing MKE Plan, Affordable Housing - Evan Casey - Jun 27th, 2024
- Zoning Changes Would Clear Path To 1 Million Residents - Jeramey Jannene - May 2nd, 2024
- City of Milwaukee releases Growing MKE Draft Plan - City of Milwaukee Department of City Development - Apr 30th, 2024
Read more about Growing MKE proposal here
Op-Ed
-
Republicans Behind the Times on Act 10
Dec 11th, 2024 by Ruth Conniff -
Time For Legislators to Work Together
Nov 30th, 2024 by State Sen. Jeff Smith -
Veterans Day Event Will Promote Peace, Not Militarism
Nov 7th, 2024 by Bill Christofferson
“The data is clear: allowing more homes types and more choices will help lower housing cost….”
I’m all for rewriting these municipal zoning laws, but this does not account for rising prices of building lumber, drywall, concrete, and labor to install everything correctly. Especially if proposed federal tariffs on Canadian lumber and H-2B visa immigration prohibitions (allows people to legally work temporarily in this country as seasonal laborers such as farmworkers, landscaping, construction) are implemented. Such costs are usually passed on to end-users, so how will allowing more home types and choices help lower housing costs with these strict limitations?
Costs always go up. Looking at numbers is only helpful if we remember that those numbers are sometimes humans. We should also be asking: Will this future housing LOOK like the kind of structures people WANT to live in. It dismays me that all of the recent construction has been centered on tall, Lego-style structures. Neighborhoods are best made by folks who can own their properties, so they feel connected to their neighbors and build a culture there with other new home owner neighbors.
Building housing is an act of creating culture. It’s not building file cabinets for people.
There needs to be empathy in this process. This process should be thoughtful…not fast.
Bold leadership in solving our housing crisis must first accept the fact that our zoning laws are ALL a product of racial segregation. The first of the zoning laws, which were a way around the SCOTUS 1917 decision in Buchanan v. Warley, zone ‘white neighborhoods as single-family residential only. Multi-family, the most accessible housing stock for working class poor and minorities, were concentrated in areas that included taverns, brothels, and other crime drawing businesses as well as near factories, railyards, and landfills.
Recognizing this historical fact will go a long way to structure housing shortages so that they address racial and class discrimination in housing.
It’s true that the costs of building materials are rising for all sorts of housing, but more affordable new housing is still possible by eliminating such unnecessary high-end options as a bathroom for every single bedroom, a second living room, a fitness room in the basement, a sun porch, a multiple-car garage, ornamental gables, dormers, and on and on. You get less for an affordable new house, but it can still make for a nice new home.
Bay View High School used to have a program where students helped rehab a house. What about Habit for Humanity upgrading and repairing homes? What about a rent to own?