City Could Sue Reckless Drivers in Civil Court
Could allow seizure of repeat offenders' cars. But is City Attorney trying to delay civil suits?
A new strategy is percolating in City Hall to deal with repeat reckless drivers: sue them in civil court.
It could allow the city to potentially impound the vehicles of repeat offenders, or even jail the offenders.
Norman created a traffic safety unit on Feb. 24. Through Jan. 9 it’s handed out 19,683 citations, including 11,075 for speeding. The officers assigned to the unit are now finding some familiar faces.
“We have 10 individuals that have been pulled over at least six times since Feb. 24,” said DeSiato. “Understanding we could pull over these individuals eight more times and their behavior wouldn’t change, we wanted to be creative.”
A civil lawsuit would be filed and a court order would be established to mandate better driving behavior. Those failing to comply could be subject to criminal or civil contempt, said DeSiato, which would open up an opportunity to seize their vehicle or have them held in jail.
“We think this is a creative and effective solution, but we don’t think this is the solution that will solve everything. It’s part of many efforts,” said DeSiato, an attorney.
An assistant city attorney authored a draft complaint.
“We were then advised that these efforts were being put on pause,” said DeSiato of a Dec. 15 message. City Attorney Tearman Spencer is holding off on implementing the measure.
“While it may seem innovative on one level, there are still other aspects of it that need to be vetted before moving forward,” said Spencer’s chief of staff Celia Jackson. “We have not decided that that issue is one we do not want to do in the City Attorney’s Office.”
Common Council President Cavalier Johnson, before he was sworn in as acting mayor, requested a formal legal opinion on the matter on Dec. 17. His first action after becoming acting mayor Dec. 22 was to declare reckless driving a public safety crisis.
“That matter is being worked on right now,” said Jackson. “It has not been completed. It has to be reviewed by the City Attorney.”
But Murphy said he had not heard of any progress until he scheduled something for public discussion: hiring an outside attorney to do the work instead.
Murphy and Perez were both critical of how they believe Spencer, who is now running for mayor, is trying to create policy instead of providing legal services.
“The City Attorney’s role is to let us know and advise us, because we are their clients,” said Perez. “I think this is crossing the line.”
“The City Attorney’s office is not trying to usurp the role of the council or usurp the role of the mayor’s office as it relates to this issue,” said Jackson. Since joining the office in July, Jackson has publicly tried to serve as a peacemaker in the fractured relationship between Spencer and the council. “I think we should be really careful about how things are being characterized.”
Murphy said he feared the assistant city attorney, whose name he did not disclose, that drafted the civil complaint would face retaliation for his action.
But he said he was happy to hear Spencer, via Jackson, was promising to move forward on the measure.
“I would much rather have them do their job than waste taxpayer money on outside counsel,” he said.
- City Could Sue Reckless Drivers in Civil Court - Jeramey Jannene - Jan 10th, 2022
- City Hall: Council Split On Hiring Its Own Attorney - Jeramey Jannene - Dec 14th, 2021
- City Hall: The Council’s War With Tearman Spencer - Jeramey Jannene - Nov 23rd, 2021
- City Hall: Council Blasts Extra Cost For Morales’ Lawsuit - Jeramey Jannene - Nov 16th, 2021
- City Hall: Council, Mayor At Odds Over City Attorney - Jeramey Jannene - Nov 16th, 2021
- City Attorney New Hire Worked For Anti-Muslim Group - Isiah Holmes - Nov 4th, 2021
- City Hall: Tearman Spencer Adds Media To List Of Those Inhibiting Him - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 29th, 2021
- City Hall: Milwaukee Will Comply With Subpoenas, But City Attorney Won’t Say How - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 7th, 2021
- City Hall: Latest City Attorney Controversy Causes Council Infighting - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 1st, 2021
- City Hall: City Attorney Accused of Politically-Motivated, Retaliatory Staff Directive - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 1st, 2021
Read more about Turmoil at the City Attorney's Office here