Wisconsin Public Radio

GOP Legislators Reject Local Sales Tax Hikes

“Dead on arrival,” lawmakers say of Evers’ enabling legislation.

By , Wisconsin Public Radio - Mar 3rd, 2021 07:52 pm
Assembly Speaker Robin Vos. Photo by Coburn Dukehart/Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism.

Assembly Speaker Robin Vos. Photo by Coburn Dukehart/Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism.

Gov. Tony Evers’ proposal to allow local governments to increase sales taxes with voter approval is “dead on arrival,” according to state GOP leaders.

The leaders foreshadowed a dim fate for the plan at a virtual forum Wednesday, where the state Senate’s top Democrat also said voters who reject raising sales taxes are “not smart,” a remark she later called a failed attempt at sarcasm and a poor choice of words.

Under the governor’s sales tax plan, which was included in his 2021-23 state budget proposal, counties and municipalities with populations over 30,000 would be able to increase sales tax by 0.5 percent, as long as the increase was approved by voters through a ballot referendum.

“There is no chance this is going to happen,” said Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, R-Rochester.  “I think the problem we are looking at, especially in Milwaukee, is systematic problems where they have made bad decisions over decades they now do not have the courage to solve. Now they want to go to taxpayers for an easy, quick fix. That is just not going to happen.”

The Wisconsin Counties Association supports the governor’s plan, saying it would provide much-needed help funding state-mandated local government programs. Other groups, including the Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce, have also come out in support of the proposal.

Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu, R-Oostburg, indicated Senate Republicans may be more open to the plan if the sales tax increases were directed toward property tax relief. But he said it’s “very doubtful” counties would choose to use the money that way.

Meanwhile, Democratic leaders urged their GOP counterparts to avoid such a quick “no” on the measure.

Assembly Minority Leader Gordon Hintz, D-Oshkosh, said many counties don’t have enough money to provide things beyond basic services.

“I hope we would get past the immediate ‘no,'” Hintz said.

Senate Minority Leader Janet Bewley, D-Mason, said some people in her district don’t have ambulance services because of insufficient revenue.

“If you call 911, you cross your fingers,” she said.

Democratic Leader’s Comments On Voters Draw Sharp Criticism

Later on in the event, Bewley took heat for saying voters who oppose referendums to pay for services are “not smart.”

After speaking about sparse emergency services in part of her district, Vos asked Bewley if the local government there had attempted a referendum to secure more funding.

“They haven’t had time yet, but they’re thinking of it,” Bewley said. “And the voters will turn it down, and then they’re going to be in the same position that they are right now.”

“If the voters turn it down, doesn’t that mean they don’t support what you’re advocating for?” Vos asked.

“Perhaps that means that they’re not smart,” Bewley said.

Bewley later clarified her remarks in a prepared statement, saying they were meant as a sarcastic retort to a previous statement by Vos, who lauded Walworth County for approving a referendum that lowered property taxes.

“After Rep. Robin Vos’ description of his voters being “smart enough” to vote a certain way, I responded sarcastically,” Bewley said in the statement. “What I should have said, is that the voters of Walworth County are not smarter than the voters in my district, and that there’s no good way to deal with a system that forces people to go to referendum in order to pay for essential services, such as having an ambulance come when you call for help.”

Republicans were quick to criticize the remark.

“I disagree with people a lot, but I don’t think people who disagree with me are dumb,” Vos said.

Others, including the Republican Party of Wisconsin, state Sen. Julian Bradley, R-Franklin, and former Lt. Gov. Rebecca Kleefisch took to Twitter to criticize the comment.

“This is shocking honesty from the Left. Liberals think that the government knows best, not you,” Kleefisch said. “Higher taxes means tighter budgets for working families. Who can afford that after the year we have all had?”

During the event, legislative leaders also weighed in on possible areas of compromise in the state budget, which they said will likely include an increase in state spending on expanding broadband internet.

“We are definitely going to have an investment in broadband,” Vos said.

Other areas of potential agreement included funding local road projects, work on I-90/94 in southeastern Wisconsin and more funding for policy body cameras.

However, Vos also noted Republicans plan to start the two-year budget “from scratch,” throwing out many of Evers’ proposals.

“We’re going to throw out his entire budget, like we’ve done before,” he said. “We’ll start from scratch.”

GOP lawmakers did the same during the last state budget process. The budget is scheduled to be complete by July 1, but could go past that deadline.

Listen to the WPR report here.

GOP Leaders Reject Evers’ Plan To Allow Local Sales Tax Increases was originally published by Wisconsin Public Radio.

3 thoughts on “GOP Legislators Reject Local Sales Tax Hikes”

  1. Mark Nicolini says:

    Here are a few facts regarding City of Milwaukee finances that readers can use to evaluate Representative Vos’ s divisive and misleading commentary:

    1. The Wisconsin Policy Forum has found that Milwaukee’s total revenues per capita are approximately 10% less than the average of peer-sized cities in the United States.

    2. Local governments in Wisconsin rely more than their peers on two revenue sources: property taxes and state aids. Since 2003, Milwaukee’s Shared Revenue amount from the State has declined $20 million (-8%) in nominal terms, and $112 million (-45%) when the 2003 amount is adjusted for inflation.

    During that same time period, Wisconsin State Government’s General Purpose Tax Revenue increased $3.46 billion, or + 66%. There is no reason that the State Shared Revenue program could not keep pace with inflation.

    3. Act 10 did not apply to local Police and Fire collective bargaining. Therefore, that legislation had a relatively modest impact on City government finances. The State mandates that Milwaukee pension benefits for Police Officers and Firefighters are a mandatory subject of collective bargaining, unlike any other City or village government, or State government.

    Since 2004 the City has eliminated almost 700 property tax-funded positions. Demand for services has not declined during that time.

    4. Employes pay for their pension contributions and the employe share of health care costs is close to 20% of the total cost of those benefits.

    I hope that readers find this information useful.

  2. RadioWires says:

    Wisconsin is not a democracy and hasn’t been for a decade. Should probably be discussed more.

  3. GodzillakingMKE says:

    Simply, Republicans are white supremacist tyrants.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us