Op Ed

Congress Should Approve Two More States

It's time to make Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico states.

By - Jan 30th, 2021 05:00 pm
Emergency blue sheeting was used as a temporary fix for roofs damaged by Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico. Photo taken January 26, 2018 by Dave Reid.

Emergency blue sheeting was used as a temporary fix for roofs damaged by Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico. Photo taken January 26, 2018 by Dave Reid.

Well, this column will sure date me. When I was in elementary school in 1959, we learned two new songs. The opening words of the first were “Your statehood we celebrate, Alaska our 49th state.” The second song substituted “Hawaii” and “50th.” The legislation approving their statehood gave more than a million Americans their full rights of citizenship. It was also a boon for the flag manufacturers, as new flags with 50 stars were suddenly in demand.

Sixty-two years later, it’s way past time to give the flag makers another boost and put two more stars on the flag. Now is the opportunity, with Democratic control of Congress and the presidency, to make Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico our 51st and 52nd states, and give full representation to 4 million of our fellow Americans who have been denied their voting rights.

Washington, D.C. has long petitioned Congress for statehood. In fact, its license plates, rather than boasting of agricultural products or scenic vistas, bear the slogan, “Taxation without Representation.” This past November, voters in Puerto Rico approved a referendum calling for statehood.

Without being states, Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico have no representation in the U.S. Senate. They have one delegate each in the House, but that delegate can’t vote.

Lack of representation is not the only reason to finally grant statehood to these two territories, which are sometimes referred to as “America’s colonies.” The lack of statehood and inability to fully govern their own affairs has led to some serious consequences.

If Washington, D.C. were a state, the attack by Trump-supporting terrorists on our nation’s Capitol might have been blunted. That’s because the D.C. National Guard could not be fully deployed to meet the threat posed by the Trump insurrectionists since the D.C. Guard is under control of the president, not the elected leader of Washington, D.C. The Trump administration limited the Guard mobilization to a small number of troops. If the Guard had been fully deployed, the Trump terrorists could have been thwarted.

In 2017, Puerto Rico suffered widespread devastation from Hurricane Maria. Lacking the resources of a state to recover from the storm damage, the island has been subjected to a severe and long-lasting economic and humanitarian crisis.

Legislation for statehood has been introduced in Congress many times but has never succeeded. Last summer, the House of Representatives voted to make Washington, D.C. a state but the effort was killed by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell.

Opposition to statehood for the territories is partially rooted in racism. D.C. is majority African American and Puerto Rico is overwhelmingly Latino. Additionally, Republicans want to keep citizens of these two prospective states disenfranchised for crass political reasons. While the Republicans put forth seemingly high-minded rationales for continuing to deprive these Americans of their right to be represented in Congress, the real reason is they fear that the good people of Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico may not choose to elect Republicans.

Republicans want to continue the potential for minority rule in the Senate since each state, regardless of population, has two senators. A thinly populated state like Wyoming has two senators, both Republicans, while California, with a population 70 times greater, also has just two senators. Republicans have historically manipulated statehood to boost their numbers in the Senate. You might wonder why the thinly populated Dakotas have four senators. The Dakota Territory was divided into two states specifically to boost the number of Republicans in the Senate.

It’s time for today’s schoolkids to learn two new songs. I’d suggest “Washington, D.C., our 51st state” and “Puerto Rico, our 52nd state.”

This column was first published by The Cap Times in Madison. 

Spencer Black represented the 77th Assembly District for 26 years and was chair of the Natural Resources Committee.

Categories: Op-Ed, Politics

7 thoughts on “Op Ed: Congress Should Approve Two More States”

  1. Wilson Perry says:


  2. Dan Wilson says:

    How many Senate votes are required? Could be a serious roadblock.

  3. Alan Bartelme says:

    simple majority to add a state, but in the Senate the bill would be subject to a filibuster so in reality you need 60 votes.

  4. GodzillakingMKE says:

    Republicans don’t like more people voting.

  5. just1paul says:

    There was a reason Washington D.C was not made a state and I don’t remember what I read about that. As for Puerto Rico I say we should.

  6. TransitRider says:

    One problem with DC statehood is what to do about the 23rd Amendment (which gives DC 3 electoral votes and explicitly empowers Congress to determine how those 3 electors are chosen).

    What’s to keep somebody from arguing that these 3 votes are IN ADDITION to what it gets as a state and/or to argue that Congress gets to pick these 3 electors itself?

    DC statehood (a good thing in my mind) gets messy unless the 23rd Amendment is repealed.

  7. Trmott says:

    I’m agnostic on this issue, but sort of curious as to what this topic has to do with Urban Milwaukee, or even Wisconsin for that matter.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us