Elliot Hughes

Can Mayor’s Plan Reduce Segregation?

New plan for 10,000 affordable homes could help integrate city, advocates say.

By , Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service - Mar 3rd, 2018 01:44 pm
Sign-up for the Urban Milwaukee daily email
The former Blommer Ice Cream Factory, at 1500 W. North Ave., is being converted into a 64-unit housing complex, with the help of tax increment financing. Photo by Elliot Hughes.

The former Blommer Ice Cream Factory, at 1500 W. North Ave., is being converted into a 64-unit housing complex, with the help of tax increment financing. Photo by Elliot Hughes.

Mayor Tom Barrett was short on details when he set a goal of building or improving 10,000 affordable housing units in 10 years in his State of the City address. But if done correctly, affordable housing advocates said, 10,000 units could take a real stab at the city’s deeply rooted segregation.
“It could take the city from being one of the cities that’s known for the segregation we’ve had for over 50 years into a more integrated city,” said Andi Elliott, CEO of Community Advocates.

During his 40-minute speech at the freshly constructed Northwestern Mutual Tower earlier this week, Barrett announced that through private partnerships, the city would soon expand a loan program designed to help low-income families improve their homes. And he said he is willing to commit significant “tax incremental financing” to spur construction of affordable housing units, both in the neighborhoods and downtown.

“Growing affordable units in these areas will make it easier for workers to get to nearby jobs,” Barrett said.

Housing advocates applauded the goal of 10,000 units in 10 years, saying that not only is it doable, but that it is a minimal starting point if the city and community want to reduce segregation, foreclosed homes and poverty. But there are many directions the city could take on its path to creating 1,000 better housing opportunities every year, they said.

For one thing, it matters where the housing would be. Barrett said the new units could be located anywhere in Milwaukee,” but added that he is “particularly interested” in seeing more affordable units in the downtown area.

SEVEN04 Place, an upcoming 60-unit apartment complex, was funded in part by tax increment financing. Photo by Edgar Mendez.

SEVEN04 Place, an upcoming 60-unit apartment complex, was funded in part by tax increment financing. Photo by Edgar Mendez.

Some housing advocates are wary about too much focus on downtown, when neighborhoods farther away struggle with foreclosed homes and rents that cost 80 to 90 percent of some families’ incomes.

“I think affordable housing needs to be sited where the people who need affordable housing are, and where they either work or want to be working,” said Tim Baack, president and CEO of Pathfinders Milwaukee. “That may or may not be in the downtown area.”

But nobody wants to see downtown — which has recently seen a boom in high-end housing and commercial development — become an area that’s only affordable for the wealthy.

If downtown and its adjacent neighborhoods can become mixed-income areas, it could help integrate Milwaukee and connect low-income households to better educational, employment and healthcare opportunities, according to Kori Schneider-Peragine, a senior administrator with the Metropolitan Milwaukee Fair Housing Council.

“We completely agree with affordable housing downtown,” Schneider–Peragine said. “We think that makes a lot of sense.”

Then, there’s the question of just how much emphasis will be placed on homeownership versus renting.

In his speech, Barrett said Associated Bank has become the city’s first corporate partner in expanding the city’s STRONG Homes Loan program. He said that partnership will add $1.5 million into the program’s coffers, which currently disperses up to $20,000 to a maximum of four low-income families every year for home improvements. The city is looking for additional partners as well, Barrett noted.

He also referenced two affordable housing developments funded by tax increment financing — the 64-unit Legacy Lofts1500 W. North Ave., and the 60-unit SEVEN04 Place, 704 W. National Ave. — as examples of the city’s more aggressive approach to luring such projects.

Elliott characterized affordable housing as the immediate need, saying too many people are struggling in unsafe properties that are far too expensive.

But Mike Gosman, executive director of ACTS Housing, which helps low-income families become homeowners, is particularly hopeful that Barrett’s housing campaign will increase homeownership. He said homeowners are more likely to fix up and care for their homes, develop relationships with neighbors and “do all the things that help to create a community that is attractive.”

“I’m hopeful, as that plan gets debated and fleshed out, that there’s a significant role for individuals and families that want to become homeowners, not just looking at affordable rental opportunities,” Gosman said. “We’d love to see how we can contribute to the 10,000 goal.”

Wyman Winston, executive director of the Wisconsin Housing and Economic Development Authority, which specializes in affordable rental properties, also acknowledged homeownership is “far better for everyone concerned.”

“I think it’s ambitious,” Winston said of Barrett’s goal. “We are committed to helping the city. I’m just waiting to hear more details.”

This story was originally published by Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service, where you can find other stories reporting on eighteen city neighborhoods in Milwaukee.

5 thoughts on “Can Mayor’s Plan Reduce Segregation?”

  1. iced tea says:

    Details to hopefully include how “affordable housing” is calculated for purposes of this effort. If “affordable” is calculated based on median incomes within a 200 foot radius of Warren Buffet’s house, then “affordable” may be a bit relative.
    Also suspecting a “giveaway” announcement for the Hillside Terrace property that I might unfairly feel is part of someone’s “five year plan”.
    Sorry for being a bit of a pooper here, TIF’s have just never worked this way anywhere. A LOT of things need to happen before a fantasy-based financing tool can be re-purposed in the fashion presented by Mayor Barrett. The goals, and values that need to be financialized with an eye toward growth of the same has just not been done here, or anywhere- otherwise this whole thing could/would/should(?) have been done years ago.

  2. GRNPAKWH says:

    The segregation problem in Milwaukee is much deeper than housing.

  3. Brian says:

    Iced Tea – I suspect they’re not using actual TIFs, but rather, the TIF extension tool which was passed by state legislature some years ago.

  4. iced tea says:

    I guess the joke’s on me…
    After finding what I think to be the intended link to the Mayor’s “State of the City” speech (provided link broken), the words “segregation”, or “desegregation” do not appear once in the text. The mention of TIF funds is a VERY small part of a much larger presentation, much of which has nothing to do with affordable, or “affordable” housing at all.
    To regain focus toward the intended direction of this article as relates to segregation, I would invite the author to travel around the city/county a bit and consider the possibility that desegregation is currently underway in many areas. A question could be “What should desegregation look like, and is this it?”
    What would happen if Milwaukee suddenly dropped out of the top ten segregated cities list?
    … just checked, 24/7 Wall St. estimates Milwaukee as the 11th most segregated by their methodology

  5. iced tea says:

    … the 24/7 Wall st. estimate of the the same name, and likely the same methodology for 2015 listed Milwaukee as #3 BTW.
    Dropping 8 slots Nationally in two years is probably something.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us