Will Historic Home Be Saved?
St. Rita's development could destroy 1875 building by architect James Douglas.
On Monday, February 12th, the Milwaukee City Plan Commission will meet to discuss three agenda items relating to a new St. Rita’s church building and a senior housing facility to be constructed by Capri Senior Communities.
As first reported by Urban Milwaukee in April, 2017, the $20 million project will include the new church along with 29 independent living units, 48 assisted living units and 26 memory care units to be built on seven lots at the south end of E. Pleasant St. between N. Van Buren and N. Cass streets. The commission meeting is the first step toward construction. The group will weigh proposals to:
- Vacate an alley
- Create a Certified Survey Map to combine seven parcels into one
- Change the existing zoning to a Detailed Planned Development.
If approved, the alley vacation will go to the Public Works Committee, while the other measures will be considered by the Zoning, Neighborhoods & Development Committee prior to a Common Council vote.
Site to be Cleared, Rebuilt
The developer’s plans call for the new construction to be built on cleared land. Existing structures on the site include a vacant former convent built in 1961, a school, a 1936 church building, a former rectory dating to 1956 and a large multifamily building originally built as a single family home in 1875. The convent site would provide the location for a new St. Rita’s church, a part of the Three Holy Women Roman Catholic Congregation. The senior housing facility would be built on the remainder, including in the vacated alley. The long-vacant convent has long been stripped of its interior, with the exception of a marble altar. The rectory was converted into four apartments in 2016. The church building, which includes vacant school rooms on the top floor, and an adjoining vacant school, is only used for religious services, including a weekly Sunday Mass. It is functionally obsolete, and is not accessible, especially for an elderly population. (The final spaghetti dinner, a custom in the church organized by Sicilians, was held in January).
These buildings are not particularly distinguished, and their loss will not be nearly as lamented as that of the Little Pink Church, the original Sicilian parish of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee, which was razed for freeway construction in 1968. Artifacts from that church, now at St. Rita’s, will be incorporated into the new church building, which is designed to evoke the beloved Blessed Virgin of Pompeii edifice in the Third Ward.
What About that House?
This leaves the remaining structure, located at 1616-18 N. Van Buren St. It was built at a cost of $2,000 in 1875 as a residence, and quite likely designed by architect James Douglas, who, at the same time, also built the Dr. Fisk Day Holbrook house, now a Wauwatosa landmark. At the time Van Buren St. was a favored location due to it being on a rise, above the miasmic river to the north and west, while sufficiently high enough to catch the occasional cleansing winds off Lake Michigan, located nine blocks to the east.
The developer, in the initial presentation in April, 2017, had little to say about the fate of the building, concentrating instead on the reincarnation of the Blessed Virgin of Pompeii on the site of the former home of the Sisters of Charity. However, due to its age, quality, and connection to the neighborhood’s historic fabric, this home is considerably more important than the other structures that are to comprise the new building site. Yet, thus far, there have been no moves made to preserve the structure, other than a recent citywide ordinance calling for the deconstruction, rather than the demolition, of structures built before 1929.
Perhaps the building merits consideration for preservation.
If the building cannot be preserved at its present site, it would make sense to have it moved. This was a quality house at the time of construction and still retains many of the James Douglas features like the elaborate trim. Most of the Douglas houses in this east side neighborhood have been stripped and remuddled.
Just as an aside, there were 4 or 5 people who stopped us when we were photographing the … house and St. Rita’s last summer (that usually does not happen). All were unhappy about the proposed demolition and were hoping something could be done to preserve the house.
Apartment Complex for Nearly a Century
By the turn of the century, the home, at what was then 782-Van Buren St., already sported an 1890 addition, which cost $1,800. This expanded the structure, on its 6,300 square foot lot, to its current 4,209 square feet of finished living area, allowing it to eventually contain six units, as it has today, according to city records. In 1916 Henry Zimmerman, the owner, had a $100 steel garage built in the rear, along the alley that is to be vacated as part of the current proposal. The structure came in crates, presumably from Sears, Roebuck & Co., and took four days in November to erect, in plenty of time for the approaching winter season. In 1919, Zimmerman paid $2,200 to “alter interior partitions and convert into a 2 family flat,” according to city permit records.
A fire on February 4th, 1996 threatened the future of this building. “Heat from candle ignited sofa, extending to building and contents,” the report noted, citing damage to the building and contents in the amount of $6,000, and prompting this perhaps prophetic “Order to Procure Permit” issued on February 22nd, 1996:
A permit must be procured, pursuant to Subchapter 4. Section 200-24 of the Milwaukee Building and Zoning Code.
However, if you decide to demolish this structure or it has burned to the ground, a demolition permit is required and can be obtained in Room 1012.
Sale Recorded this Week
The Dentice family retained ownership of this property, assessed at $378,000, and the adjacent vacant lot at 1612 N. Van Buren St., valued at $154,000, until December 11th, 2017, at which time the two properties, with a total assessed valuation of $532,300, were sold for $650,000 to St. Rita Property, LLC., which shares a Waukesha address with Capri Senior Communities, the developer. The sale was entered into the city records on February 6th.
We know that the St. Rita’s Spaghetti Dinner tradition will continue during construction of the new church, and will be hosted in the interim in the cafeteria of St. Joan Antida High School, two blocks to the south on E. Ogden Ave. But other questions, including the staging of the project, and the fate of this building remain unknown. A query directed to the developer requesting the plans for this structure received a wait-and-see response on February 6th:
We will be disclosing all of the details about the development at the February 12th meeting. We would be happy to respond to any unanswered questions after the plan commission.
Amy Schoenemann, AIA
Real Estate Development Manager
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits, all detailed here.