Jeramey Jannene
Eyes on Milwaukee

Council Delays Action On Shopping Carts

Stores need more notice, they decide, on ordinance requiring locks on all carts.

By - Nov 28th, 2017 04:00 pm
Abandoned shopping cart on N. 6th St. Photo by Nik Kovac.

Abandoned shopping cart on N. 6th St. Photo by Nik Kovac.

A proposed ordinance that would require shopping carts in the city to have a locking mechanism was sent back to the Public Safety & Health Committee for further debate. The legislation, introduced by council newcomer, Ald. Chantia Lewis, was referred back to committee because many Common Council veterans couldn’t believe there wasn’t widespread opposition from stores.

Lewis sponsored the measure because she has found that recovering abandoned shopping carts has become a daily activity for the Department of Public Works. “This is in response to the shopping carts that have become an unnecessary blight on the community,” she explained. Using the example of a Save-A-Lot store in her district, she said the up-front cost of the carts is from $125-$150/each, while the security system costs $25 per cart. “This is not a costly investment to protect your investment,” the northwest side alderwoman said.

The Save-a-Lot grocery store at 6410 N. 76th St. adopted a security mechanism commonly associated with Aldi’s grocery stores, a mechanical 25 cents deposit that is released by the cart when it is returned. It typically costs a store $25 to install this mechanism. The result is a win-win according to Lewis, who said “we have better things for our city services to do.”

The council has previously debated such measures, but had backed down from passing any proposal because of overwhelming opposition according to longtime council member Robert Bauman. The downtown and near west side alderman, who asked to be added as a sponsor on the measure, said “why they don’t care about these carts is beyond me.”

The legislation would authorize the city to impose a $250-per-cart fine on stores that fail to install the locking mechanisms. Ald. Nik Kovac asked Lewis if the measure would allow the city to fine stores that don’t comply, but still fail to lose a cart. She replied that it would, however, the legislation specifies that one of the acceptable prevention measures allows stores to comply with the law and not install a locking mechanism. It reads: “Assign personnel employed directly or indirectly by the cart provider to be primarily responsible for preventing removal of shopping carts from the cart provider’s premises.”

Other security options listed in the legislation include the security deposit method associated with Aldi’s, the installation of bollards or other barriers to prevent their removal or the installation of “devices to disable and render inoperable any cart removed from the cart provider’s premises.” One such device used by some Milwaukee stores is a magnet that locks on the cart when it crosses an invisible barrier on the property’s perimeter. Lewis notes those locks have varying degrees of success.

“I recognize the problem and sometimes solutions can create new problems,” Kovac said. He along with many others on the council advocated further debate on the measure.

Council members Michael Murphy, Robert Donovan, Bauman and Kovac all said they weren’t sure if written notice had been given to those potentially affected by the legislation. With no formal answer available other than Lewis’s assurance that she hasn’t received negative feedback, Kovac and Donovan both moved for the measure to be referred back to the Public Safety and Health Committee and affected parties to be properly noticed of a public hearing. The move unanimously passed.

The legislation will likely have a public hearing at the Public Safety and Health Committee on December 7th. If the committee takes action on the item, it could be back before the full council on December 19th.

Current regulations in the city require shopping cart owners to mark the carts with their name and address. Abandoned carts recovered by the city become city property after five days if they remain unclaimed.

Kovac On the Job, Retrieves Shopping Cart

Kovac with the saved shopping cart. Photo by Nik Kovac.

Kovac with the saved shopping cart. Photo by Nik Kovac.

One thing that Lewis referenced repeatedly in today’s meeting was a cart that has sat for days on the corner of N. 6th St. and W. Highland Ave. Kovac, in a moment of levity, promised to go claim it before lunch.

He had previously told the council that his second job was at Otto Wenz‘s Sentry on N. Downer Ave. (now a CVS store) and that he enjoyed the diversion of being dispatched to retrieve carts Wenz would spot in the neighborhood.

True to his word, as I finished my lunch Kovac was texting me photos of the cart being returned to T.J. Maxx at the Shops of Grand Avenue. The alderman is on the job.

If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits, all detailed here.

9 thoughts on “Eyes on Milwaukee: Council Delays Action On Shopping Carts”

  1. Rich says:

    The Jewel-Osco (when it was one) at Humboldt and North in Riverwest voluntarily (?) installed an electronic wheel locking system when the store first opened. Pick-N-Save abandoned the system when they took over the store around 2007 and carts have been roaming the neighborhood ever since; previously they were all lined up at the sidewalk edge — couldn’t even get them to the bus stop

  2. Connor says:

    I can see it now the “Rumba Shopping Cart.” If it sits idle for more than 10 minutes, it drives it self back to the cart corral.

  3. Jim says:

    I propose we fine the stores for any shoplifting they allow to occur where the product or packaging is later discarded as litter. Seems equivalent.

  4. Amy Butterfield says:

    Didn’t realize this was a problem! Why don’t those who find the carts just wheel them back to the store they’re from? How far away from the stores are these carts wandering?? Wouldn’t it be cheaper for stores to offer an incentive for their regular shoppers who return an AWOL cart, like $25 off your next grocery shop of over X amount… versus spending $25 on every cart in the store? OR wouldn’t it be cheaper for stores to schedule an employee to spend 1 hour driving thru the neighborhood a couple times a week, seeking and retrieving any runaway carts (cuz they aren’t making $25 an hour!) OR people can easily enough use neighborhood apps like Nextdoor to report the cart locations to the store, OR the store could use Nextdoor to report locations their carts were seen, and each person who returns one of the listed carts gets a grocery voucher or something. Seems like there could be a much cheaper solution using creative thinking.

  5. Tim says:

    Amy, you mean like the 25¢ deposit required on Aldi or Save-a-Lot carts?

    It works and others return the cart to claim the quarter, that is what this ordinance would require.

  6. Ben says:

    I think we should BAN ALL SHOPPING CARTS.

    If we could only save one bus station from having a shopping cart nearby – it would ALL BE WORTH IT!!!!!

  7. When I was a kid in the 70’s, the local Kohl’s food store gave us neighborhood kids candy bars for returning carts to the store. That was incentive enough for us and it worked!

  8. MollyO says:

    If shoppers would take responsibility for using a cart, there would not be a problem.
    Seems people today only care about what’s good for them – screw anyone else.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us