Michael Horne
Bar Exam

Club Brady Has 130-Year History

There's been a tavern in odd trapezoidal building since 1885. Blame it on the lake.

By - Aug 10th, 2016 06:14 pm
Club Brady. Photo by Michael Horne.

Club Brady. Photo by Michael Horne.

This trapezoidal building with a little cut-out corner has been on the southwest corner of E. Brady St. and N. Warren Ave. since around 1885. It was almost certainly built as a tavern, and it is identified as a saloon in a map from 1894. Since it dates to an era before the city required building permits, it does not appear in the city records until April 25th, 1933, when the city demanded that the one-story frame store and dwelling to the east be torn down because it was “dilapidated and insanitary.” That lot remained vacant for many years, except during the winter, when Christmas trees would be sold here.

But the old corner building stood, and on September 12th, 1934 Frank G. Luke took out a permit to occupy the place as a newly legal tavern. “What was the previous use of the property?” the city asked. The answer: “Tavern.” Even during Prohibition, as with so many taverns in town.

By 1942 the place was owned by Anton Busateri, as the Sicilians began moving east into the old Polish neighborhood on Brady Street west of N. Humboldt Ave.

Tony changed the front entrance, installed brick piers and covered the walls and ceilings with decorative boards in June, 1942. By 1948 the place was the Sparrow Club, at a time when avian names were popular for bars.

Perhaps it lacked the luster of New York’s Stork Club, but the Sparrow served food and drinks to its customers. In 1950 the upstairs rooms were converted to living quarters and sleeping rooms. There was great postwar demand for housing, and many single men lived above taverns (during sleeping hours) and inside the taverns themselves (when not at work.)

There were six rooms and a toilet upstairs. And you think it’s a pain sharing a bathroom with your spouse! How about five fellow factory workers after a night of drinking beer downstairs?

In 1951 the storefront was altered with the addition of four-inch stone veneer, which remains, as do the two plate-glass windows that opened the place up to the street. In 1953 two oil tanks were installed in the basement, replacing the coal stokers that heated the place. Progress came slow to Brady Street. By 1953 many people were installing gas heating, which is now nearly ubiquitous in Milwaukee

As late as 1976 Busateri still owned the place, although he had decamped to a residence in Bayside north of Brown Deer Road. In 1978 John Schroeder ran it as Rain Dancer, with an Andeker sign out front. In September, 1979 it was time for the N. Warren Ave. facade to be redone at its lower level. At the same time, the entire upper floor of the building was re-sided in the silly slanted cedar batten board siding that remains today, covering up what is probably a cool looking 1885 building. By 1980 it operated as Dr. Feelgood, an appropriate name for that pharmaceutically influenced era. Busateri still owned the building. The establishment had a steam table, a back bar, and carryout food.

In 1981 Mark Sherman, a busy operator, applied to run the place as Harpo’s. By 1984 it was operated by Michael D. Lee, the current owner. In 1986 the old vacant lot to the east was filled in with a 650-square-foot addition that gave us the bathrooms still in use today.

Club Brady Today

The corner entrance to the bar is shaded with a canopy, with glass blocks on either side of the door. Once in, you are immediately confronted with a couple of stairs, and, immediately to your left, a long bar that fills the entire east wall of the tavern on N. Warren Ave. Even though your haven’t even had a sip, the place is a bit disorienting, since the building has an acute angle here, where you would expect a normal right angle. This is thanks to the irregular street grid, which has been in place since 1835, so there is not much we can do about it now. The skewed street grid itself is due to the course of the shoreline of Lake Michigan, two blocks to the east. That has been in place since the Pleistocene era, so we are truly at the mercy of history here. Across the street, the Nomad World Pub has the equal but opposite situation. My goodness, this would be a great place to sit and do our geography and geometry homework!

Shot and any tap beer for $5. Photo by Michael Horne.

Shot and any tap beer for $5. Photo by Michael Horne.

Let’s get to the bar. If you had been paying attention, you would have noticed a chalkboard outside listing the daily specials. Since a shot and any tap beer will run you $5 from 5 to 9 p.m. Monday through Friday, this seems like a reasonable choice. Let’s get one as we look around the joint.

Behind the bar is a Brunswick back bar that probably dates to the 1951 remodeling. It has the sleek lines and curves and nicotine-stained blonde wood customary to the era. As the sun sets on Brady Street, and the light dims, with the gentle glow of the wood, the mirrors can prove to be very attractive indeed, but then I am naturally partial to mirrors wherever I encounter them.

The mirrors are flanked by fluted glass pillars that can be lit from behind. A curved cabinet at the end, filled with bobblehead dolls, is a novelty, but not nearly as much as a giant Milwaukee Harp Lumiere perched atop the bar itself, with a little stuffed bear hanging on to it for dear life. The floor is old and oak. Nearly every pillar in the room is equipped with a little table for your drinks, or for you and your friends to visit and chat.

Before you know it, the beer is here, and is set on the copper topped bar, another nice touch. The bar runs all the way to the end of the building, taking a little jog at the end, where a kitchen and steam table used to be. There are a surprising number of windows here, but the place stays appropriately dim thanks to the dark paint and the wooden paneling on the walls.

Pool table. Photo by Michael Horne.

Pool table. Photo by Michael Horne.

You can get a clear picture of the whole place right from the barstool, but the doctor recommends a little exercise, so grab your beer and go for a walk. You will find a pool table illuminated by a Pabst Blue Ribbon Beer sign in the center of the room, which is a sort of gathering spot, especially when people are playing partners, which takes forever. We will slowly walk around these loafers. Maybe they’ll get the hint. A gaming device overlooks Brady St., but I wouldn’t know how to work it. Elsewhere in the room is an air hockey table that looks like it came from the Starship Enterprise. Fortunately that noisy machine was silent during our visit. There is also a game where you can bowl (it’s called Beer Ball), and an electronic dartboard. A large mirror covers the back wall, and makes the place seem larger than it is.

After a trip to the bathroom, you’ve made a circuit and it’s time to return to the bar. On your way, take a look at the Art Deco chrome-plated heating vent on the floor. It is rather stylish and abstract.

Then return to your Brady Street drinking experience, which is rather stylish and, shall we say, more corporeal.

On Tap - Sponsored by Lakefront Brewery

  • Miller Lite
  •  Bell's Two Hearted Ale
  •  Guinness
  •  Lakefront IPA
  •  Lakefront Riverwest Stein
  •  Leinenkugel's Summer Shandy
  •  New Glarus Spotted Cow
  •  Smithwicks
  •  Stella Artois
  •  Stella Cidre

Photo Gallery

The Verdict

  • Trade Name: Club Brady
  • Location: 1339 E. Brady St. Milwaukee. Historical address: 397 Brady St. (1894); 363 Brady St. (1910)
  • Neighborhood: Lower East Side
  • Subdivision: Subdivision of Lots in Blocks 196-197-198
  • Phone Number: 414-278-0188
  • Website: http://www.clubbrady.com/
  • Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ClubBradyMKE. Active site
  • Twitter: @ClubBradyMKE
  • Description: Built around 1885 in an irregularly shaped building on busy Brady Street, this has almost certainly always been a saloon. Somewhat enlarged and improved over the years, it benefits from long-term ownership and stable management. Oversized amusements include air hockey and basketball, along with centrally located pool table. Lots of ledges for your drinks.
  • Signature Drink: Monday-Friday, shot and any tap beer $5 until 9 p.m. Keeps the inventory circulating.
  • Capacity: 143
  • Restrooms: 1 Men’s, 1 Woman’s
  • Year Established: As Club Brady, 1984. Previously Harpo’s (1981), Dr. Feelgood (1980), Rain Dancer (1978) Frankie’s (1957), Sparrow Club (1948) and other incarnations lost to the mists of time.
  • Year Building Constructed: City records say 1885, with a 650-square-foot addition to east dating to 1986. Many remodelings over the years.
  • Estimated Annual Rent: 2,248square feet at $20.51/s.f.=$46,106.48 per annum according to City Assessor’s calculations. Operator owns building through holding companies.
  • Property is assessed at $85,600 for the 3,425 sq. ft. lot [$25.00/sq.ft.] and $349,400 for the 3,736 sq. ft. building for a total assessed valuation of $435,000. Owner bought building 10/31/2011 for $360,000.
  • Property taxes of $14,346.94 are Paid in Full.
  • Property Owner: MDL, LLC., Michael D. Lee, agent
  • Business Owner: MP on Brady, Inc. Michael D. Lee [D.O.B. 09/25/1958] 80%, Michael W. Ross [D.O.B. 09/06/1957], 20%
  • Business: Tavern; Alcohol Sales 100% of revenue.
  • Walk Score:  94, Walker’s Paradise. City Average: 61
  • Transit Score: 56, Good Transit. City Average: 49
  • Games of Chance: A number of amusements suitable for late in the evening. Television screens
  • Game of Skill: Pool Tale
  • Aldermanic District: 3rd Ald. Nik Kovac
  • County Supervisor District: 10th Supreme Moore Omokunde
  • Police District: 1

Hours of Operation

Is Open? Day Open Close Expected Customers Age Restriction
True Sun 1:00 p.m. 2:00 a.m. 100-200 None
True Mon 6:00 p.m. 2:00 a.m. 100-200 None
True Tue 6:00 p.m. 2:00 a.m. 100-200 None
True Wed 6:00 p.m. 2:00 a.m. 100-200 None
True Thu 4:00 p.m. 2:00 a.m. 100-200 None
True Fri 4:00 p.m. 2:30 a.m. 100-200 None
True Sat 1:00 p.m. 2:30 a.m. 100-200 None

If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.

7 thoughts on “Bar Exam: Club Brady Has 130-Year History”

  1. Christina Zawadiwsky says:

    Thanks for all the interesting facts about Club Brady, Michael Horne! I used to go there long ago, and will now have to return to observe all the elements that you’ve written about in this article!

  2. Sam says:

    Some people call it Club Shady. I call it some of the cheapest drinking on Brady Street.

    Thanks for the History lesson!

  3. Edward McDonald says:

    This is the best bar on the lower eastside. Some of Milwaukee’s best bands played at Harpos during the mid -80’s and 90’s – like the BoDeans , Paul Cebar and the Milwaukeeans to name a couple. The owner Mike Lee is committed to customers having a good time without going broke doing it. That’s the Milwaukee way. Love the history of the place and it confirms Club Brady is still the place for the little and big guy just looking to have a Milwaukee style good time. Thanks for sharing.

  4. MF says:

    If you really like the Art Deco abstract air vent covers, you can find them — the exact same one pictured — at Home Depot for about $12 a piece.

  5. Mr. Suburbs says:

    “…but then I am naturally partial to mirrors wherever I encounter them.” Brilliant.

    Please keep these articles coming. They offer a fascinating history lesson on what is truly one of our city’s greatest assets – sometimes-wonderful architecture in always unique buildings, generations of history written into our culture, and a sense of place that is very simply not found in other cities. Also, a while back, a group of friends did a “Classic Milwaukee Taverns” bar crawl and fully one half of our of drinking destinations were culled from your Exams. A great time was had by all.

  6. Unfortunately the era of Frankie (Tomasello) is passed over, but as Tomasello’s it was a favorite haunt in the ’60s & ’70s of literary UWM students (& others) & then the counterculture (Kaleidoscope offices were almost opposite on Brady St.)., owned by the little bachelor guy with a Corvette & a fixation on Frank Sinatra, as played on the popular jukebox featuring jazz & classical music for the cozy booths under stained-glass windows, until he sold out & opened what is now Jamo’s on Arlington Pl.

  7. James Kobs says:

    I lived with Frankie in 1967, He accused me of flirting with his 19 year old girlfriend. We remained friends till the end. Alot of fun

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us