Christa Westerberg
Op-Ed

Cops in Shootings Should Be Promptly Named

Police Chief Flynn waited more than five months to identify officer who shot Dontre Hamilton. The public deserves better.

By - Nov 5th, 2014 02:19 pm
Get a daily rundown of the top stories on Urban Milwaukee

Following the Aug. 9 police shooting of Michael Brown, an unarmed teenager in Ferguson, Missouri, citizens and the public demanded to know the involved officer’s name. The Ferguson Police Department stirred national attention, and some outrage, by waiting six days to reveal it: Officer Darren Wilson.

Wisconsin has Ferguson beat. On April 30, 2014, a Milwaukee police officer shot Dontre Hamilton 14 times, killing him. Hamilton, 31, was unarmed and had a history of paranoia and schizophrenia, according to his family. Yet Milwaukee police did not confirm the identity of the officer who shot him for more than four months.

True, the department disclosed the officer’s name to Hamilton’s family in July, more than two months after the incident, and the family later shared it at a community forum. But the department did not publicly name Officer Christopher Manney as the shooter until October.

The department said it was just following past practice and was waiting to see whether the district attorney would file charges against the officer before releasing a name.

Milwaukee Police Chief Edward Flynn

Milwaukee Police Chief Edward Flynn

But in fact, Chief Edward Flynn identified Manney after the department’s internal investigation was completed, when he announced the officer’s termination from the force. No charging decision has yet been made.

There is obvious public interest in knowing the identities of law enforcement officers involved in shootings. Prompt identification of officers helps preserve public confidence in law enforcement and ensure correct information. It also alerts the public earlier if other complaints and concerns have arisen about the officer.

Jonathan Safran, an attorney for the Hamilton family, told WISN 12 that citizens have a right to this information because “this is a publicly paid individual employed by the city of Milwaukee, and the police department is being paid by taxpayer dollars.”

Waiting for an indeterminate date to identify officers involved in citizen shootings can unreasonably delay release of this important information. Internal and criminal investigations can stretch for weeks or months, as they did in Hamilton’s shooting.

Complicating matters, there seems to be little consistency in how police departments approach this issue. Some routinely release the names of officers involved in fatal shootings immediately after those events.

Three days after the 2012 fatal police shooting of Paul Heenan, an unarmed local musician, Madison police released the name of the involved officer. News media then reported on other incidents involving the same officer, including an instance where he was suspended for shooting at the tires of a fleeing car.

The officer, Stephen Heimsness, later resigned after the department sought his dismissal for charges unrelated to the shooting.

In Ferguson, police said they withheld the name due to death threats against the officer and concerns for his safety. “Right now, people want it so they can destroy that person’s life,” Police Chief Thomas Jackson said. “That’s the only reason that group’s asking for it.”

While Ferguson was surely a charged situation, the police chief’s statement reflects cynicism and an unfortunate distrust of citizens. The department’s six-day delay also contributed to brewing frustration, lack of confidence in the department, and bad information. Hackers even attacked the department’s computers to learn the name, which resulted in the wrong person being named.

The Milwaukee Police Department, which has promptly named officers involved in other fatal shootings when it believes they have acted heroically, was wrong to withhold Manney’s name for so long.

There are many downsides, and little benefit, to waiting for internal or external reviews to be completed before providing the public with accurate information about officer-involved shootings. The Milwaukee Police Department and other police departments should reconsider their practices.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (www.wisfoic.org), a nonprofit group dedicated to open government. Christa Westerberg, at attorney with McGillivray Westerberg & Bender, is the group’s vice-president.

4 thoughts on “Op-Ed: Cops in Shootings Should Be Promptly Named”

  1. Andy says:

    Many downsides with little benefit to withholding names? I’m sure the officers receiving death threats feel the benefits are quite substantial. The only benefit listed is trust in our police force. Releasing a name does little to reinforce any trust. Meanwhile, we see a frenzy of people who threaten to do harm to the police officers. It’s not just law enforcement… we’ve seen the same in situations involving citizens defending themselves as well.

    For the safety of everyone involved, it’s best to wait until actual charges are filed, or at least the investigations are complete, before the names are released.

  2. PMD says:

    Andy, has Manney received credible death threats? The California Supreme Court recently ruled on this matter. They ruled that the name must be released unless there is specific evidence that disclosure would pose a safety threat. “Vague safety concerns that apply to all officers involved in shootings are insufficient to tip the balance against disclosure of officer names.” Reasonable?

  3. Casey says:

    When a shooting occurs on the street the suspect normally isn’t named until they are formally charged correct? Shouldn’t there be a similar standard here?
    What I think would really help as far as transparency is concerned are the body cameras being proposed. Allows for a much quicker outcome as to what events really took place which in turn would allow for quicker turn around in notifying the public.

  4. Sean Williamson says:

    Releasing a name right away would be the worst thing possible…..

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us