Building Info

Second German Methodist Episcopal Church, 140 W. Garfield Ave. Photo by Jeramey Jannene.
  • Address:
    124-128 W. Garfield Ave.
  • Taxkey:
    3530188000
  • Status:
    Completed
  • Assessed Value (Land):
    $19,900
  • Assessed Value (Improvements):
    $191,500
  • Assessed Value (Total):
    $211,400
  • Assesment Year:
    2023
  • Year Built:
    1887

Photos

Content referencing 124-128 W. Garfield Ave.

Mayor Sidesteps Another Controversial Historic Designation

Mayor Sidesteps Another Controversial Historic Designation

Property owner objected to designating East Side properties.

Feb 11th, 2026 by
Council Approves Historic District Over Owner’s Objections

Council Approves Historic District Over Owner’s Objections

Vote is unanimous. Former church also gets historic designation without opposition.

Feb 10th, 2026 by
Church Is Historic, Commission Rules, Though Developer Objects

Church Is Historic, Commission Rules, Though Developer Objects

Neighbors back designation for unique 1880s church. Will council approve?

Jan 12th, 2026 by
Buyer Revealed For Potentially Historic Church

Buyer Revealed For Potentially Historic Church

Plus: Who can apply to demolish your house?

Dec 18th, 2025 by
What’s The Future For This 138-Year-Old Church?

What’s The Future For This 138-Year-Old Church?

Demo permit request triggers preservation nomination.

Nov 20th, 2025 by
Eyes on Milwaukee: Pattee Buys Historic Church, Two Neighboring Houses
Eyes on Milwaukee

Pattee Buys Historic Church, Two Neighboring Houses

1887 church will be renovated says developer.

Jan 6th, 2023 by

Building data on this page, including assessment information, was last updated on April 5, 2024

See something wrong? Want to report an issue? Contact us.