Erik Gunn

GOP Legislators Want to Repeal Mask Mandate

A joint resolution would terminate Evers' public health orders.

By , Wisconsin Examiner - Jan 22nd, 2021 11:24 am
Gov. Tony Evers. Photo courtesy of the Office of Gov. Tony Evers

Gov. Tony Evers. Photo courtesy of the Office of Gov. Tony Evers

After repeatedly complaining about emergency declarations that Gov. Tony Evers has issued in the face of the coronavirus pandemic, Republican lawmakers for the first time have begun formal action to block him.

Senate Republicans introduced a joint resolution Thursday that would undo the governor’s most recent COVID-19-related emergency executive order and the new statewide mask order that accompanied it. Evers announced the orders on Friday, Jan. 15; they took effect Tuesday, Jan. 19.

The resolution, SJR-3, has been referred to the Senate Committee on Senate Organization. As of Thursday, the panel did not have a meeting scheduled; however, the Legislature has a floor period scheduled for Tuesday, Jan. 26 through Thursday, Jan. 28.

The resolution declares that “the public health emergency declared by the governor in Executive Order #104 on January 19, 2021, in response to the COVID-19 coronavirus, is unlawful and is terminated,” and that “termination … applies to all actions of the governor and all emergency orders issued pursuant to the declaration of the public health emergency.”

If the Republicans’ resolution makes it to the floor of both the Senate and the Assembly, it is almost certain to pass, ending the emergency declaration and mask order. Republicans hold majorities in both chambers, and individual Republicans in the Senate and the Assembly have consistently criticized Evers for the mask orders he has issued starting in late July.

A simple majority of each chamber is sufficient to pass a resolution, which does not require the governor’s signature. No Republican lawmaker has publicly expressed support for the governor’s health emergency orders or mask mandates.

Evers has declared new 60-day health emergencies, accompanied by mask mandates, beginning July 30, and subsequently on Sept. 22 and Nov. 20, and again with the Jan. 19 order.

Evers first issued an emergency executive order in response to the coronavirus pandemic on March 12, expiring on May 11. The law authorizing the governor to declare an emergency puts a 60-day time limit on each declaration, after which the emergency can only be extended with the consent of the Legislature.

The Senate joint resolution declares that all of the subsequent orders are effectively extensions of the March 12 order and therefore illegal without the Legislature’s approval.

The conservative law firm Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty has made the same argument in a lawsuit it first filed against Evers after the July 30 emergency declaration. That suit is now before the Wisconsin Supreme Court, which heard arguments in November but has not yet announced when it will issue a ruling.

The Evers administration argues that the emergency declarations were issued in response to specific new circumstances as the pandemic surged, rather than extensions of the first emergency or subsequent ones, and are therefore legal.

The only other time that the Legislature’s Republican leaders have taken steps to block actions of the Evers administration in response to the pandemic was in the spring, after the governor extended the Safer at Home order that the administration first issued March 25.

In that instance, Assembly Speaker Robin Vos (R-Rochester) and the Senate majority leader at the time, Scott Fitzgerald (R-Juneau), filed a lawsuit that argued that order could not be extended without the Legislature’s approval. The Wisconsin Supreme Court sided with the GOP lawmakers on a 4-3 vote, throwing out the Safer at Home extension on May 13. (Fitzgerald has since left the state Senate after he was elected to Congress Nov. 3.)

A spokesperson for the governor did not immediately respond Thursday to a request for comment about the Senate resolution.

Reprinted with permission of Wisconsin Examiner.

More about the Coronavirus Pandemic

Read more about Coronavirus Pandemic here

More about the Statewide Mask Mandate

Read more about Statewide Mask Mandate here

3 thoughts on “GOP Legislators Want to Repeal Mask Mandate”

  1. JMcD says:

    I wonder how severe a health crisis has to become before the Republican legislature and WLL realize that science is the answer, action is the answer, mandates are the answer? Lawsuits aren’t the answer. When 400,000 people in this country die from it? And our economy has been devastated from it? Oh wait, that is now. So, I ask, what will it take? How bad does it have to be? In the meantime, I guess they think, why not throw a wrench in the spokes of the effort to curtail the spread? Some of you elected these people.

  2. Thomas Williams says:

    Immoral actions aren’t limited to simple personal acts against a particular individual but also those actions which effect a group of people! Racism is immoral. Sexism is immoral. And the list goes on. Failure to care for others and protect them from a disease – isn’t that also immoral? It baffles me to try and understand who cares so little about themselves, their family, neighbors that they would ignore the scientific community and its advice to do something so simple as wear a mask! Do these people also refuse to wear shirts, shoes, or seatbelts because those are also mandates?

  3. frank a schneiger says:

    There are two useful quotes to put these men’s actions, as well as our times, in context. First, the historian T.W. Maitland once said that “We should always beware that what now lies in the past once lay in the future.” Johnson, Vox, Fitzgerald and the rest of this group of nihilists and know-nothings all count on short memories, but when this pandemic and its impacts are looked at in the rearview mirror, they will have a lot to answer for.

    The second quote is from Herodutus: “All arrogance will reap a harvest rich in tears.” Let’s hope so, and, let’s hope that, for once, some of the tears are those of the perpetrators of this ongoing human disaster. And, as JMcD says in his comment, “Some of you elected these people.”

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us