Bruce Murphy
Murphy’s Law

Richie Rich

Republican Senate candidate Eric Hovde’s basic message is simple: elect me because I’m wealthy.

By - Jul 20th, 2012 02:15 pm
Eric Hovde

Eric Hovde

Back in the 1960s, the rich were different. Top CEOs then earned about 30 times more than the average worker. Today they earn about 300 times more and the wealth gap between the rich and the rest of us is the biggest in history, comparable only to that of the Roaring Twenties.

When a plutocrat like George Romney ran for office in the 1960s he was modest about his good fortune, and careful to disclose the details to voters. Romney released 12 years tax returns to the media.

Today’s rich don’t feel they owe the public any such disclosures. George’s son Mitt Romney has released one year’s tax return, and an estimate of the next year’s. But Eric Hovde, a Republican candidate for U.S. Senate in Wisconsin, has refused to release any tax returns.

On the one hand, Romney and Hovde claim their success in business makes them uniquely qualified to serve in government. On the other hand, they won’t let us see the details of how that money was made. Both Romney and Hovde have major investments in an off-shore tax haven like the Cayman Islands, but refuse to allow any scrutiny of the deals.

The information Hovde has released could be hardly be more vague: the Senate disclosure form he was required to fill out shows his assets range anywhere from $58 million to $240 million, with holdings in myriad stocks, banks and real estate. Either figure puts him among the top 1 percent of wealthy Americans and probably among the top .001 percent, richer than all but a few Wisconsinites.

Hovde holds himself up as an example of American Dream, who built his wealth through hard work and skill. But he came from a wealthy Madison real estate family and became CEO of Hovde Properties, originally founded by his grandfather. Few Americans start with such an advantage.

Hovde says he spent his life in the private sector, “creating jobs.” But he made most of his money as manager of a hedge fund, Hovde Capitol Advisors, with just nine employees. The Republicans’ transformation of wealthy people into “job creators” has apparently become so complete that the actual number of jobs created no longer matters.

Hovde is a fierce critic of the bank bail-out, but appears to be the classic Wall Street insider. As Politico has reported, Hovde Capital made more than $180 million in investments in financial companies that took federal bailouts. Hovde doesn’t deny this, but says his own companies weren’t bailed out.

Hovde has proposed lowering corporate taxes from 35% to 25%; he concedes this would help his companies. Of course, since he hasn’t shared his tax returns, there’s no way to evaluate the payoff — probably many millions of dollars — this would gain him.

It’s the no-shame school of campaigning. Increasingly, you have wealthy candidates like Romney and Hovde who oppose Warren Buffet’s proposed tax hike for the wealthy, while declining to disclose what they would gain personally.

Hovde’s shameless style can be seen in other examples of his campaigning. He echoed Michele Bachmann, falsely claiming that under President Obama, the U.S. Department of Transportation went from one employee making $170,000 a year to 1,700 employees earning this. In fact, nearly all of this upgrade in salaries for employees occurred under Obama’s predecessor, President Bush.

And Hovde has joined those Republicans practicing the new McCarthyism, which brands classic Democratic liberals as communists. He has accused Tammy Baldwin, the Democratic candidate for U.S. Senate, of having a philosophy grounded in “in Marxism, communism, socialism, extreme liberalism.”

But it’s the issue of America’s rising inequity where the Hovde world view becomes brutally clear. At one forum, Hovde complained the media is always writing a “sob story” about  “oh, the person (who) couldn’t get, you know, their food stamps,” as opposed to “what’s happening to the country as a whole.”

But what’s happening to the country is the worst recession since the Great Depression. Among those hardest hit are some 45 million people — one in seven Americans — forced to rely on food stamps. Many are workers who earn so little they must depend on such assistance.

Back in the 1960s, when the federal government had launched a War on Poverty, you weren’t likely to hear a wealthy candidate for office dismiss the plight of the poor as a sob story. But we have reached a point where the rich not only seem removed from such concerns, but almost glory in their ability to accumulate wealth and avoid taxes.

Lindsey Graham, the Republican senator from South Carolina, has declared that Mitt Romney shouldn’t be criticized for using off-shore tax havens because “it’s really American to avoid paying taxes, legally.” Of course, it’s typically the wealthy who can afford the investments and legal advice to fully exploit such tax loopholes.

Hovde has clearly modeled his campaign after that of Ron Johnson, even using the same consultant to do his ads. Like Johnson, Hovde has quickly spiked his standing in the polls by bankrolling his campaign, spending $4 million in TV and radio ads and booking another $1.5 million in future ad buys.

It’s his personal fortune that makes this strategy possible. And that fortune, when you come down to it, is Hovde’s main qualification for office. Vote for me because I’m rich, the message seems to be, but don’t dare ask how I got so wealthy.

A different version of this column first appeared in the Madison weekly Isthmus.

Categories: Murphy's Law

5 thoughts on “Murphy’s Law: Richie Rich”

  1. PaulS says:

    His wealth is the only job qualification he has. Post-Citizen United, it might be the only one he needs.

    Aside: this article shows the solid historical research a reader needs to understand how *far* we’ve fallen, how low the standards are, and how threatened the nation is by the pathology of greed.

  2. Tristan says:

    If you think Mitt should release his tax returns, what about the billions held secretly in for-profit companies by the non-profit LDS Church? Some LDS members are standing up for transparency- sign here to support the Mormon resistance!

  3. getch says:

    @paulS I hope MJS and UrbanMKE are not your only sources of information. Its like only looking at fox news for info, really one should take a look at what everyone is writing. Often times the writer will cater towards their audience. Mr. Murphy, I enjoy your articles and everyone elses, with that being said…. I look forward to work on Mark, Scott, and Tammy, the others running for senate, since you already wrote a article on Tommy.

  4. Casandra says:

    Our Lord Jesus Christ transformed water into wine. Mr. Romney & Mr. Hovde managed a greater miracle. They have converted ordinary income into long term capital gains through “carried interest.”

  5. Edith Wagner says:

    Do you suppose Hovde’s company will do what Ron Johnson’s company did and hand him a bonus that is just slightly higher than the personal investment he made in his campaign? Such sweet deals the rest of us could never imagine. I spend it, it’s gone, no one coming up behind me feathering my nest.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us