Jon Anne Willow

Judge rules that bargaining law not in effect

By - Mar 30th, 2011 08:47 pm
Get a daily rundown of the top stories on Urban Milwaukee

Mike Huebsch. Photo courtesy Dept. of Administration

In a stunning move at the end of business Wednesday, Wisconsin Department of Administration Secretary Mike Huebsch released a statement saying the DOA would indeed continue to enforce Act 10, also known as the budget repair bill. This despite a court order just yesterday from Dane County Circuit Court Judge Maryann Sumi, who promised to rule by Friday on the legality of the bill’s passage.

Here is Huebsch’s statement:

“I have a legal obligation to execute all laws pertaining to my department that have been passed by both houses of the legislature, signed by the Governor, and published into law. The Department of Justice has concluded that 2011 Wisconsin Act 10 has met those requirements and is now effective law. My legal counsel agrees with the Department of Justice’s legal reasoning and conclusions. Accordingly, it is my duty to administer that law.

“On the other hand, Judge Sumi made clear in comments from the bench yesterday that she intended to prevent further implementation of Act 10 by anyone including, apparently, non-parties such as myself and the Department of Administration. Yet, the TRO she issued fails to state that Act 10 is not in effect. In fact, Judge Sumi declined a request to declare that Act 10 was not lawfully published. It is unclear how she can issue an order binding non-parties to a case who have not had their day in court.

“Because of the questions this TRO raises, its legal effect on my implementation of Act 10 is also unclear. DOA will continue to monitor court proceedings and work with legal counsel and the Department of Justice to determine an appropriate course of action.”

Foreshadowing of Huebsch’s decision can be found in another statement, released yesterday by the Dane Country Republican party in response to Sumi’s ruling.

Its text reads:

“For those people that don’t know, the state of Wisconsin has an executive branch, a legislative branch, and a judicial branch. The executive branch has the job of carrying out the laws and setting the agenda for his administration. The legislative branch has the job of passing laws. And the judicial branch has the job of interpreting and applying the laws and ensuring their constitutionality.

By Judge Sumi’s action today, it is apparent that she has forgotten those roles and she thinks that her job is to be a member of all three branches. The Republican Party of Dane County believes it is time for the judicial branch to stop being judicial activists. If they want to legislate the laws, they need to run for political office not judicial office.”

However early Thursday morning, Sumi ruled that the state law, which sharply curbs most collective bargaining rights from public employees, is not in effect.

In a two paragraph order, published at 8:15 this morning,  Sumi’s ruling states:

“Based on the briefs of counsel, the uncontroverted testimony, and the evidence received at the March 29, 2011, evidentiary hearing, it is hereby DECLARED that 2011 Wisconsin Act 10 has not been published within the meaning of (state statutes), and is therefore not in effect.”

Despite his statements last night, Dept. of Administration Secretary Mike Huebsch said today that Gov. Scott Walker’s administration would comply with the ruling.

“While I believe the budget repair bill was legally published and is indeed law, given the most recent court action we will suspend the implementation of it at this time,” Huebsch said.

Home page photo courtesy “Hispanics for School Choice” via Flickr

0 thoughts on “UPDATED: Judge rules that bargaining law not in effect”

  1. Anonymous says:

    Sumi is a hack, and I bet deep down she wishes this would go away. The more people look into her connections to unions the more it looks like she should have recused herself in the first place. She is embarrassing herself and the judicial branch simultaneously.

  2. Anonymous says:

    Walker is the hack. His illegal actions will not stand and he will be recalled less than a year from now. Republicans way over-reached with this. The smackdown to Walker and his hack senate cronies over the next year will be legandary. Watch.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Thanks, I really needed a good laugh before bed

  4. Anonymous says:

    There is a far better chance that Obamacare will die in the courts than Walkers budget repair bill. First, there wasn’t anything illegal about the actions take by Senate Republicans, Truth Senate Dems broke the law and that is fact. Next, Supreme Court Shirley Abramamsmsmssam will need to recuse herself for even more obvious reasons than Sumi should have. Third, you can hardly call it an over-reach when the vast majority of public sector employees do not have collective bargaining like those removed by this law. Currently 20 states, and NONE of the Federal employees have what was being cried about here at the capitol. By the way that number will soon grow as Ohio has just passed similar law as WI. Fourth, lack of public support. The recall will not occur, the attempt may be made but voter fraud won’t get you over the hump on this one. The more time passes, the less emotion, the worse for you. People will have a hard time connecting to something they do not have themselves, never the less agree to vote for more taxes to support such lavish benefits! I’d tell you to go to bed but it sounds like you are already dreaming.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us