Voters Worried About PFAS in Water
69% are worried, poll shows. But Evers and Legislature can't agree on how to address problem.
Wisconsin residents’ concerns about PFAS-contaminated drinking water have become another election-year issue, although elected officials deadlocked again last week over how to spend $125 million set aside to fight the problem.
A Marquette University Law School poll, conducted 10 months ago, found that 69% of registered voters statewide were “very” or “somewhat” concerned about the so-called “forever chemicals” contaminating their drinking water, while 28% dismissed those concerns. In 2022, 61% of poll respondents worried about PFAS.
“Majorities of voters across the public spectrum are concerned about PFAS,” Professor Amber Wichowsky, chair of Marquette University’s Political Science Department and director of the university’s Civil Dialogues program, said in a WisconsinEye interview after the latest failure of elected officials to resolve how to spend the $125 million.
Wichowsky said PFAS, chemicals found in many domestic and fire-fighting products that have been linked to cancer, will be an election-year issue for some local voters. “It could be very much at play in some parts of the state, especially when we do have new [legislative district] maps in some places that will be competitive,” Wichowsky said.
Emily Berge, president of Eau Claire’s City Council and the League of Wisconsin Municipalities, said in the WisconsinEye interview that her community had to shut down half of its wells and faces costs of up to $22 million to correct PFAS contamination. Redirecting other wells and being atop a deep aquifer means the city’s water is now safe.
Berge noted that new legislative district maps mean Eau Claire will be part of three Assembly districts, instead of just one. “As [districts] become more competitive, hopefully this issue will come up more,” Berge said. “At the local level, we talk about it a lot.”
But Berge said concern about PFAS contamination varies widely, because some of the cities and villages the League represents have tested for PFAS while others have not. Testing poses a catch-22 problem for local officials, Berge explained. “When you test, it’s there and you need to have a solution…Some [municipalities] are very concerned, and some maybe not quite yet.”
Democratic Gov. Tony Evers vetoed the latest plan of Republicans legislators for the $125 million, which was approved last year. Evers said the state Department of Natural Resources (DNR) – and not Republican lawmakers – should administer the funds and the GOP plan would give “polluters a free pass from cleaning up their own spills.” DNR has been without a secretary since Nov. 1.
Evers tried to force the Legislature’s Finance Committee to meet last week to release the $125 million, but Republicans who control the panel ignored that request.
Sen. Howard Marklein and Rep. Mark Born, committee co-chairs, said the governor could call a meeting of the panel but that doesn’t require it to meet or take action. “We are disappointed in your disregard for a co-equal branch of government, as well as the legislative process,” Born and Marklein told Evers.
Republican Sen. Eric Wimberger, a member of the budget committee and sponsor of the Republican plan, accused Evers and Finance Committee Democrats of staging a “publicity stunt.”
The federal Environmental Protection Agency recently announced a national standard for PFAS that municipal water systems will have to meet. Evers, Republican legislators and business groups have also clashed over proposals for DNR to set a state PFAS standard.
But about 30% of Wisconsin residents get their drinking water from private wells, Wichowsky noted. “There’s no (PFAS) standards there.”
Urban residents used to be more concerned about PFAS than rural residents, Wichowsky said. Now, “that difference is no longer there.”
Wichowsky will hold focus groups statewide this summer to ask local residents about PFAS contamination worries and how they get information about the problem.
With the drop in local media organizations, she added, “Not all Wisconsinites have access to local news coverage” about PFAS contamination.
Wichowsky said she hopes that the Capitol “stalemate” will be resolved, although the Legislature has adjourned for the year. “Talk about the greatest opportunity to find common ground – clean drinking water…Everyone recognizes that we want that.”
Hopefully, Berge added, Capitol officials “can get their act together” and agree on a compromise that releases the $125 million.
“Cities and villages didn’t necessarily put the PFAS in our water, but we’re tasked with getting it out,” Berge added. “You have to pay for it somehow.”
Steven Walters started covering the Capitol in 1988. Contact him at stevenscotwalters@gmail.com
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.
More about the PFAS Problem
- Lawmakers At Odds Over Releasing Health, PFAS Funds - Erik Gunn - Jun 6th, 2024
- Wisconsin Senate Votes to Override Governor’s Vetoes - Baylor Spears - May 15th, 2024
- Gov. Evers Sues Republican Legislators for Continued Obstruction of Investments Intended to Address Pressing Challenges Facing Wisconsin - Gov. Tony Evers - May 13th, 2024
- Legislators Agree on Opioid Plan, Still Withhold PFAS, Hospital Funds - Erik Gunn - May 8th, 2024
- Gov. Evers Again Calls Republican Lawmakers into Special Meeting to Urge Immediate Release of $140 Million to Fight PFAS Statewide, Respond to Hospital Closures in Western Wisconsin - Gov. Tony Evers - May 6th, 2024
- The State of Politics: Voters Worried About PFAS in Water - Steven Walters - Apr 22nd, 2024
- EPA Slaps Two PFAS Chemicals With Superfund Law Designation - Danielle Kaeding - Apr 19th, 2024
- DNR Responds To EPA’s Designation Of PFOA And PFOS As Hazardous Substances - Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources - Apr 19th, 2024
- Evers Won’t Rule Out Court Challenge to Force Release of PFAS Funds - Danielle Kaeding - Apr 16th, 2024
- Gov. Evers Vetoes PFAS Bill, Calls Special Meeting of Budget Committee - Baylor Spears - Apr 10th, 2024
Read more about PFAS Problem here
The State of Politics
-
Turnover High For Republican Convention Delegates
Jun 10th, 2024 by Steven Walters -
One-Fourth of Assembly Will Be Newbies
Jun 3rd, 2024 by Steven Walters -
Ron Johnson’s Curious Stand on Abortion
May 28th, 2024 by Steven Walters