AG Objects to Relaxed Lead Pipe Rules
Kaul joins other Attorneys General in objection to new EPA rules for lead pipe removal.
The EPA’s proposed changes to the Lead and Copper Rule (LCR) would give water utilities up to 33 years to replace lead lines that are problematic. Kaul joined with nine other attorneys general, including AGs from Illinois, Minnesota and Pennsylvania in filing an objection to proposed amendments to the rule.
The original 1991 rule is facing its first major revision. Some proposed changes would strengthen the rule — such as requiring lead service line inventories and making them available to the public — while other changes would significantly weaken requirements.
The latter could spell bad news for anyone in the public that wants their drinking water protected from lead and is the focus of the AG’s submitted comments.
“We must ensure that lead doesn’t endanger the safety of our drinking water,” said Kaul. “Lead is a highly toxic heavy metal that can adversely affect almost every organ and bodily system. It is particularly dangerous for children since their developing brains and nervous systems are more sensitive to its damaging effects.”
EPA Administrator Andrew Wheeler announced the proposed changes standing on a Green Bay riverfront last October. Last March, Wisconsin policies received an “F” grade for failing to protect children from lead in water at school and daycare facilities in an in-depth report from the Environment America Research & Policy Center.
Lead exposure, he notes, can cause such health problems as premature birth, learning disabilities, delayed physical development for children, and cardiovascular and kidney problems for adults.
Quoting the EPA to the EPA, Kaul’s comments include a link to its website page with the subtitle: EPA and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) agree that there is no known safe level of lead in a child’s blood. Lead is harmful to health, especially for children.”
The group of attorneys general write that the existing rule requires water utilities to collect samples from a “small number” of drinking water outlets that are “associated with lead service lines or plumbing materials. They assert that some of the elements they deem harmful in the plan may violate the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA).
“The undersigned Attorneys General recognize that reducing the impacts associated with lead in drinking water will not include a quick, one-size-fits-all solution, but a comprehensive program that takes into account the varied resources of water systems, while still protecting America’s drinking water supply and complying with the SDWA’s mandates,” they wrote.
“The rule’s proposed reduction in the lead service line replacement rate — from seven percent to three percent — may also violate the SDWA anti-backsliding provision that prohibits the EPA from weakening existing drinking water standards. Decreasing the current replacement rate would give water districts up to 33 years to replace lead service lines that test above actionable levels.”
The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources also submitted comments by Wednesday’s deadline. “I read that 55,000 entities submitted comments on the rule,” said Steve Elmore, program director of the DNR Bureau of Drinking Water and Groundwater. “I hope the EPA will take all the comments that have been provided into account and make some changes.”
He said that the current rule is already very complex and said the changes are a mixed bag of improvements, elements that will be difficult to implement and others that could harm public health. He also pointed out that some provisions would be unfunded mandates.
“To run a program like this,” said Elmore, “we need resources.”
Reprinted with permission of Wisconsin Examiner.
- Evers Budget Has Green Goals - Danielle Kaeding - Feb 18th, 2021
- New Program for Lead-Poisoned Children - Matt Martinez - Dec 26th, 2020
- EPA Requires Lead Testing for Schools, Day Cares - Danielle Kaeding - Dec 22nd, 2020
- Lead Testing Down During Pandemic - Edgar Mendez - Nov 6th, 2020
- Op Ed: Lead Poisoning and a Listening Session - Carol Diggelman and Ann Batiza - Oct 27th, 2020
- SafeHomes initiative expands lead abatement efforts for a lead-free Milwaukee - Ald. Marina Dimitrijevic - Oct 27th, 2020
- Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevention Efforts Expand in Wisconsin - Wisconsin Department of Health Services - Oct 26th, 2020
- Green Bay Replaces Every Lead Pipe - Megan Hart - Oct 7th, 2020
- EPA Unveils New Lead Regulations - Danielle Kaeding - Oct 2nd, 2020
- Op Ed: More Water Infrastructure Funding Needed - Radhika Fox and Kevin Shafer - Jul 26th, 2020
Read more about Lead Crisis here