Trans-Rights Advocates Say Hovde, Trump Ads Are ‘Dehumanizing’
Candidates have attacked opponents' support of access to gender-affirming medical care, allowing transgender women and girls to compete in sports
Transgender pride flags line the sidewalk in Washington, D.C. Ted Eytan (CC BY-SA)
Campaign ads for the presidential and senate races have dominated Wisconsin’s airwaves in the last few months, addressing key issues like immigration, the economy and reproductive rights in an attempt to sway voters in the swing state.
But in recent weeks, some ads supporting former President Donald Trump and Republican Senate candidate Eric Hovde have also focused on the rights of transgender Americans.
During the first half of October, the Trump campaign and its supporters spent tens of millions of dollars on ads attacking Vice President Kamala Harris’ past support of certain rights for transgender people — including access to gender-affirming care that is deemed medically necessary for detained immigrants and incarcerated people.
“Kamala is for they/them. President Trump is for you,” one such ad says.
“What he’s saying is, ‘You’re watching this TV ad. And what I need you to know is that you are not the person she cares about. She cares about this nebulous they/them pronoun,’” Marquette Journalism and Media Studies professor Patrick Johnson told WPR’s “Wisconsin Today.”
Senate candidate Hovde’s campaign is using a similar strategy. His ads attack Democratic opponent Tammy Baldwin and Harris for allegedly, “allowing men to compete in girls’ sports,” and “funding a clinic that offers transgender therapy to minors without parents’ consent,” a claim that has been proven false.
Sheri Swokowski is a retired Army colonel from Wisconsin with 35 years of service, and she is the highest-ranking openly transgender U.S. Army veteran. She also serves on the ACLU of Wisconsin’s Board of Directors and is a longtime advocate for transgender rights.
“The intent of the ads is to incite fear and division by shaping trans people as somehow being different than the norm,” Swokowski told “Wisconsin Today.”
Johnson said he is doubtful that focusing on transgender issues will pay off for Republicans on election day.
“I don’t know if the people he’s trying to target with these ads aren’t already voting for him,” Johnson said. “(When) you look at polling, you don’t necessarily see LGBTQ issues or transgender issues being something that is going to sway independents and moderates.”
As a member of the transgender community, Swokowski said seeing the frequent anti-trans ads has a real effect on her.
“It’s a constant reminder that we live with a lot of discrimination,” she said.
The consequences of the recent anti-trans political climate are tangible, according to a recent study by The Trevor Project. Researchers found states that passed anti-transgender laws between 2018 and 2022 saw up to a 72 percent increase in suicide attempts among transgender and nonbinary youth.
Abigail Swetz, Executive Director of Fair Wisconsin, said that the anti-trans rhetoric she’s seeing in political ads is dehumanizing.
“These people are your coworkers and neighbors. These children are members of families, and that means that they deserve respect and love and trust,” Swetz said. “I think it’s really important that we try to center humans in the conversation, because that is the exact opposite of what’s being done to these people (through) these attacks.”
She also thinks they divert attention from issues that are more relevant to voters.
“(It’s) a pretty ridiculous distraction from the actual issues facing Wisconsinites,” Swetz said. “Certain candidates are trying to turn people — specifically trans people — into issues, as opposed to focusing on the issues people truly care about.”
Trans-rights advocates call Hovde, Trump ads focusing on transgender issues ‘dehumanizing’ was originally published by Wisconsin Public Radio.
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.
All Trans and Trans-allies: Please vote Harris this Nov.
Sitting this out or voting third party does nothing to stop Trump from winning and making this a reality.
This piece about a soon-to-be-over political campaign and its Republican appeals touches on some of the most basic things in our lives.
First, how the age of reaction that started with white backlash in the 1960s and is now Trumpism focuses almost entirely on the groups that made progress through the women’s rights, civil rights, gay rights and rights of those with disabilities movements. It is about “putting them back in their place.”
Second, there would appear to be an eternal human need for scapegoats, and, when few actually believe that Republicans will make there lives better, the most effective appeal is to promise to make the lives of “the others” worse.
Third, like everything else, we are – once again – as a society, becoming accustomed to cruelty, bigotry, and dishonesty. All acceptable if they are used in the name of “otherization.” As Tolstoy said, “There are no conditions to which people cannot become accustomed, especially if the see everyone around them living in the same way.”
Fourth, as evidenced in the Trump/Vance rallies, you cannot dehumanize others without dehumanizing yourself.
And, finally, at some point in the not too distant future, this is all going to be in the rear view mirror. Let’s hope that the questions asked then are not: how did we let this happen? And what has this generation left behind? People have often thrown the term “fascism” around too loosely, but this is a case in which the shoe fits. And, we should remember, there were lots of people who liked the evils of fascism, and others, like Hovde, who went along with the program to get something out of it. We have lots of both groups in this country.
frank:
Kudos to you for conveying this message so calmly, eloquently and accurately. The only point you make that I would take issue with is that this will all be over in the not too distant future. I have a much darker view of the future of the Republican Party, and my belief that the messaging that has been coming from them for years is not going to disappear soon, even if Trump does. There are not enough Liz Cheneys and Adam Kinzingers still occupying elected positions that have the balls to stand up and scream “ENOUGH”!!! Until that happens, the current Republican Party will continue to swirl downward into the vile, hate-filled vortex of their own making, with new spineless, opportunistic mouthpieces like JD Vance leading the country-dividing charge.
My fear, TosaGramps1315, is that the Republican Party will get smart and go back to dog whistles while pushing the same hateful legislation and political action, so that it may fly under the radar and to casual observers they may even seem moderate.