Common Ground, Residents Blast Housing Authority at Board Meeting
HACM board meets in person for first time since January, chair pledges they want to help.
“We hear you and we are responding.”
That was the message from Housing Authority of the City of Milwaukee (HACM) board vice chair Brooke VandeBerg, who was serving as acting chair as dozens of HACM residents and Common Ground Southeastern Wisconsin representatives packed the first in-person HACM board meeting since January.
Speaker after speaker told VandeBerg that the agency was falling short and more was needed.
“We shouldn’t have to live with rats and roaches and bugs,” said Lapham Park complex resident Vivian Jones.
“When we raise concerns, you merely move the managers around,” said Roye ‘Chris’ Logan, a Mitchell Park resident. “HACM’s biggest problem is bad management from the top down.”
More than 20 speakers were given two minutes each, ostensibly to address a five-year plan mandated by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). HACM, as Urban Milwaukee previously reported, is already under a corrective action plan from HUD.
“I am glad you are here today. We want to hear from you,” said VandeBerg.
But the only other board member in the room was Darian Luckett. Several HACM employees were in the room, including Executive Director Willie Hines, Jr. Board chair Sherri Reed Daniels, a HACM resident, was participating virtually and Irma Yépez Klassen was absent.
“The board fully supports meeting in person and quite frankly it hasn’t always been the board’s decision whether we met in person or not,” said VandeBerg. “We do want to have more chances for public comment.”
But as challenged by Logan and other speakers, VandeBerg said the board and HACM’s role Wednesday was to receive feedback, not have a dialogue. Formal responses, which must be submitted to HUD, are to be released prior to the October board meeting, said HACM Chief Operating Officer Ken Barbeau.
VandeBerg wants the Common Council to approve Mayor Cavalier Johnson‘s appointments or reappointments, including hers, in the next month. Only four of the seven seats are currently filled.
One of the new nominees, Karen Gotzler, was in the crowd and taking notes. Several HACM employees, including Hines, also appeared to spend much of the meeting writing down comments.
The council, in a June press release, said it wants to see a defined plan for the board. Council President José G. Pérez previously said he wants the council to take a deliberate approach to reviewing the nominees and has separate legislation pending to overhaul how appointments are made.
VandeBerg said the board, individually, is already visiting properties. She said she visited College Court, subject of a new class action lawsuit from tenants, in recent months. But those in the room shouted that she wasn’t getting the full story and that unannounced tours weren’t welcome.
“We have challenged our HACM leadership to take action to investigate and hold their teams accountable, and above all to provide safe, cleaning and welcoming environments. Doesn’t mean that all of that is going to happen overnight, but I want you to know that the call has been made,” said the acting chair. “We will conduct performance appraisals of our current HACM leadership and we will be transparent with our findings and recommended actions.”
Vandenberg, a former city employee turned vice president at Associated Bank, stressed that the board is made up of volunteers. “I think HACM needs board members to continue to function and operate and I believe in providing safe housing to the city,” she said.
Hines, after the public hearing concluded, said the agency is working to change. He said the new capital plan reflects resident concerns.
“We will work to improve the current conditions when it comes to pest control,” he said. Hines said additional third-party public safety agencies are being hired. “I have heard you today and thank you for coming down.”
He also said the council needs to act on the board members. “We do recognize the challenge of not having adequate board members,” said the former council president.
HACM provides housing to approximately 5,000 households in its own properties and, with federal vouchers, houses an additional 6,000 households in privately-owned properties.
Common Ground, in launching its campaign in March 2023, said it has interviewed or collected information from more than 1,200 HACM residents, spanning 17 properties, since 2020.
The broad-based, nonprofit coalition has recently drawn criticism from the mayor, who called its actions “Trumpian” in a press scrum two weeks ago. Johnson took issue with Common Ground’s allegation that he continues to support Hines only until he can retire with a full pension.
Legislation Link - Urban Milwaukee members see direct links to legislation mentioned in this article. Join today
If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.
Related Legislation: HACM Resolution R13500
More about the Common Ground Housing Authority Campaign
- Mayor, Common Council Overhauling Housing Authority Board - Jeramey Jannene - Nov 12th, 2024
- In Special Meeting, Housing Authority Advances Controversial Privatization Deal - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 12th, 2024
- City Hall: Housing Authority Delays on Privatizing Voucher Management - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 9th, 2024
- City Hall: HACM Moves To Outsource Vouchers, Common Ground Blasts Plan - Jeramey Jannene - Oct 8th, 2024
- Common Ground, Residents Blast Housing Authority at Board Meeting - Jeramey Jannene - Sep 11th, 2024
- Lawsuit Filed Against City Housing Authority Over College Court Conditions - Jeramey Jannene - Aug 28th, 2024
- HUD Public Housing Officials Visit Milwaukee - U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development - Aug 19th, 2024
- Federal Officials Will Meet With Mayor, Housing Authority, Residents - Jeramey Jannene - Aug 13th, 2024
- Common Ground To Mayor – ‘Why Are You Protecting Willie Hines?’ - Jeramey Jannene - Aug 1st, 2024
- Open Letter to Mayor Johnson – Why Are You Protecting Willie Hines? - Common Ground Southeastern Wisconsin - Aug 1st, 2024
Read more about Common Ground Housing Authority Campaign here
Political Contributions Tracker
Displaying political contributions between people mentioned in this story. Learn more.
- December 29, 2020 - Cavalier Johnson received $400 from Karen Gotzler
- July 29, 2020 - Cavalier Johnson received $100 from Karen Gotzler
- December 5, 2019 - José G. Pérez received $100 from Karen Gotzler
- September 17, 2019 - Cavalier Johnson received $284 from Karen Gotzler
- May 8, 2019 - José G. Pérez received $100 from Karen Gotzler
- April 17, 2019 - José G. Pérez received $100 from Karen Gotzler
- December 11, 2018 - Cavalier Johnson received $250 from Karen Gotzler
- December 11, 2018 - Cavalier Johnson received $250 from Karen Gotzler
- May 26, 2017 - Cavalier Johnson received $50 from Karen Gotzler
- December 9, 2016 - José G. Pérez received $50 from Karen Gotzler
- May 5, 2015 - José G. Pérez received $10 from Cavalier Johnson
Tell me again WHY the City of Milwaukee is in the housing rental business? Does it make a profit, or operate at a loss time after time after time? And, since my guess is that it is operating at a loss, how much of one. Asking for a taxpaying friend (and myself). Perhaps these numbers need to be shown in the local media (in both print and on the local news stations).
I wonder why Mayor Johnson, with his excellent political skills, is sitting on the sidelines and refusing to work with the concerned residents in coming to a resolution of the issues? Why is he reluctant to start a process to replace Mr. Hines who let this disaster grow and become a major issue quality of life issue for these residents?
@DAGDAG – In many respects, the city government is not really in the housing rental business. The federal government (HUD) is the real backer of the housing authority.
HACM, as a legacy of a different era, has ‘City of Milwaukee’ in its name, but its ties are increasingly weak. There is not regularly an explicit line item transfer from the general fund to HACM in the city budget and HACM makes a $1m payment in lieu of taxes back to the city.
As an authority, it operates on a breakeven basis. The city, as the photo from yesterday’s meeting shows, does contribute things like space for meetings and clerical resources (HACM’s records appear in Legistar).