UW-Madison Had 1,015 Conflicts of Interest
No university had more conflicts since 2012 for researchers getting federal health grants.
![Bascom Hall on the University of Wisconsin campus. Photo by Rosina Peixoto (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons](https://urbanmilwaukee.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Bascom_Hall_in_Madison.jpg)
Bascom Hall on the University of Wisconsin campus. Photo by Rosina Peixoto (Own work) (CC BY-SA 3.0), via Wikimedia Commons
Conflict of interest disclosures are required by the NIH whenever a researcher receiving taxpayer funded grants gets outside compensation related to their field of study valued at more than $5,000 or more in a given year.
On Dec. 6, ProPublica published an article citing a NIH database of disclosures, which it reports has not been made public before. The article reports that such financial conflict of interest disclosures are required “because outside income from interested parties can potentially affect researchers’ objectivity and influence the design and findings of their taxpayer-subsidized work.”
Eric Campbell, a professor of medicine and director of research at the Center for Bioethics and Humanities at the University of Colorado, told WPR that UW-Madison has led the nation in entrepreneurial activity among faculty through the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation (WARF), which was created in 1925. The foundation’s website says it is the “designated patent and licensing organization for UW-Madison.”
Campbell said the interplay between business and researchers is a necessary function of transferring findings into the commercial market.
“And the existence of a conflict alone, unless it is extremely egregious, is not the issue,” said Campbell. “The issue is how well do universities manage these.”
He said generally, public universities like UW-Madison have been better about managing researcher conflicts than private research universities.
Brian Fox, UW-Madison associate vice chancellor for research, policy and integrity, told WPR that financial conflicts of interest among researchers run the gamut but are managed by the university.
“That might be anything,” said Fox. “That could be a cash payment, ownership of a privately held startup company, it could be service on a board of directors.”
“So, we’ve always been very broad in the past but a consequence of that is we’re reporting more than other universities,” said Fox. “And we’re evaluating how we can do better on this, be more targeted.”
Fox said many UW-Madison researchers are also inventors that may hold multiple patents.
“And one thing that UW-Madison does is we let our investigators be owners of companies,” Fox said. “We actually encourage them to go out, make startups, try to transfer their discoveries to the private sector. And so we let people be owners of companies. They need to report it and they do.”
Fox said his office has been working with faculty to review conflict of interest reporting policies this year in hopes of streamlining the process while maintaining adherence to federal rules.
Conflicts of interest among researchers at UW-Madison are reviewed by a faculty governance group called the Conflict of Interest Committee. It is made up of a chair and 12 to 18 members that are tasked with reviewing conflicts and determining whether they need to be managed by the university.
Fox gave an example of a researcher who also operates a startup company. He said a management plan for that individual would likely include prohibitions on that person buying supplies from their own company or using university property without administrative approval.
Listen to the WPR report here.
UW-Madison Researchers Filed More Conflict Of Interest Statements Than Any Other Institution Since 2012 was originally published by Wisconsin Public Radio.
Editor’s note: Wisconsin Public Radio is a service of the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
