Wisconsin Public Radio

Hagedorn Says He’ll Keep Politics Off Bench

High court candidate has faced weeks of controversy for writings on gays, abortion.

By , Wisconsin Public Radio - Mar 7th, 2019 12:00 pm
Get a daily rundown of the top stories on Urban Milwaukee
Brian Hagedorn. Photo courtesy of the Friends of Brian Hagedorn.

Brian Hagedorn. Photo courtesy of the Friends of Brian Hagedorn.

Wisconsin Supreme Court candidate Brian Hagedorn doesn’t believe politics should play a role in the state’s highest court.

The conservative state appeals court judge has been under fire for comments and blog posts regarding gay rights and abortion. Hagedorn pledged Wednesday during a panel discussion at the Milwaukee Press Club to put his personal views aside while on the bench.

“The real critical question is do you have a judicial philosophy that says we are going to lay aside whatever our personal views are and we’re going to apply the law faithfully,” Hagedorn said. “I do have that philosophy. I have carried that out, and I don’t have confidence my opponent is going to do the same on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.”

Hagedorn and state Appeals Court Judge Lisa Neubauer are seeking to replace Justice Shirley Abrahamson, who has served the court for more than four decades. Neubauer was invited to the press club event, but declined.

Hagedorn and Neubauer sit on the Waukesha-based District II Court of Appeals. Hagedorn was appointed to the Court of Appeals by former Gov. Scott Walker in 2015 and was elected in 2017. Before that, he was Walker’s chief legal counsel.

Hagedorn’s pledge to be non-partisan was challenged by journalists who pointed out that while serving as Walker’s chief legal counsel, he sent out a personal email in support of then-Supreme Court Justice David Prosser. The email said Prosser’s defeat could stop Walker’s agenda.

Hagedorn defended the email, saying it wasn’t partisan politics. He said under Abrahamson, he knew how all of his cases would be decided, regardless of merit.

“My opponent has held (Abrahamson) up as a model,” Hagedorn said. “That’s a way we can’t go. We need a court that is faithful to the application of the law.”

Hagedorn helped draft Act 10, Walker’s controversial bill ending public-sector collective bargaining for most public sector workers in Wisconsin. When asked Wednesday, Hagedorn would not commit to recusing himself from cases involving Act 10 legislation.

Hagedorn’s personal beliefs regarding same-sex marriage and abortion have caused previous supporters to back away. Last month, the Wisconsin Realtors Associationpulled its endorsement and asked for $18,000 in campaign contributions back after reports about Hagedorn’s ties to a school that bans gay students, teachers and parents.

The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported Wednesday the U.S. Chamber of Commerce won’t spend money on this year’s race because of Hagedorn’s ties to the school. The national organization often gives money to Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce to help conservatives in court races, according to the Journal Sentinel.

“The fact that I expressed mine when I was a law student, and now, doesn’t make me unique,” Hagedorn said. “Regardless of my personal views from law school, or today, my job is to be faithful and apply governing precedent to the United States Court.”

Listen to this report

Supreme Court Hopeful Hagedorn, Former Walker Aide, Says He’ll Keep Politics Off The Bench originally was published by Wisconsin Public Radio.

One thought on “Hagedorn Says He’ll Keep Politics Off Bench”

  1. rob johnston says:

    I am concerned that the hate evident in Brian’s statements began in college (perhaps earlier in his life than that. We don’t know.) He has not changed his opinion about gays, lesbians, and people who believe that abortion is ok when the circumstances are examined. That opinion shows he has a blind eye to the thoughts of many other people. For one thing they in conscience may think differently about sex. He seems to be afraid to listen to others. It appears that he makes judgments based only on his feelings. He is afraid of change. How can he be a thoughtful Supreme Court justice. The challenge of the law makes changes necessary as circumstances change. That growth allows us to become great and allows our country to continue to be great.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us