Brooklyn Boy at Milwaukee Chamber Theatre

Milwaukee Chamber Theatre closes its 34th season with playwright Donald Margulies’s semi-autobiographical play. It focuses on a novelist who, after two attempts at the great American novel, gets it right on the third try to critical acclaim and popularity by penning a semi-autobiographic novel called Brooklyn Boy. With the vague notion that this achievement may endear him to his dying father and save his withering marriage, the author attempts to re-draw his life as he thinks it should be. But new found fame and a re-discovered past proceed to pull him in opposite directions.

James DeVita is understated and charming as Eric Weiss, the writer suffering through a mid-life crisis. As the character is quietly devastated to learns that success cannot alter the relationships with his father and soon to be ex-wife, actor DeVita expresses frustration and anger with a unique deft without resorting to simply yelling.

The supporting cast members all neatly avoid playing into stereotypes. Robert Spencer as Eric’s father Manny Weiss is able to create a rich and complicated relationship with his son. Rebecca Rose Phillips gives depth as an enamored groupie and Tom Klubertanz is lovable as Ira, Eric’s childhood friend who forces him to reminisce and ultimately deal with his grief. Rounding out the cast is Darrel Cherney, Michelle Lopez-Rios and Julie Swenson in strong and multi-faceted performances.

Although much of the play is a reflection on Weiss’s life growing up in a Jewish family and community, director and MCT Producing Artistic Director C. Michael Wright makes sure the play is not just a Jewish story. Brooklyn Boy is relatable to anyone, regardless of religious or ethnic background.

Brooklyn Boy runs through May 3rd at the Broadway Theatre Center. For tickets call 414.291.7800 or visit MCT’s website.