Baldwin, Marshall Lead Bipartisan Group Calling on Regulators to Reject Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern Rail Mega-Merger
Lawmakers argue merger will lead to higher costs, worse service for farmers, manufacturers, and consumers
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Today, U.S. Senators Tammy Baldwin (D-WI) and Roger Marshall (R-KS) led Senators Martin Heinrich (D-NM), John Hoeven (R-ND), Steve Daines (R-MT), Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), Tim Sheehy (R-MT), and Chuck Schumer (D-NY) in calling on federal regulators to reject a mega-merger between Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern. The Senators argue that the merger would drastically reduce competition in freight rail, raising costs on consumers and worsening already poor service for American farmers, manufacturers, and businesses that rely on freight rail to get their goods to market.
“If approved, this transaction would represent the most significant consolidation in the freight rail industry in decades and would reshape the U.S. freight rail network and supply chain. Specifically, we are concerned that a merger of this magnitude could increase costs, reduce transportation options for shippers, undermine reliable service, and further diminish competition in an already highly consolidated industry,” wrote the Senators in a letter to the Surface Transportation Board (STB), which is currently reviewing the merger. “Given these significant risks to rail shippers, consumers, and the broader U.S. economy, we urge the Board to reject the proposed merger.”
Since the 1950s, the rail industry has consolidated from more than 100 Class I freight railroads to only six today. This consolidation has left many manufacturers, utility companies, agricultural producers, and small businesses with limited competitive options for moving their goods. In recent years, shippers across the country have raised concerns about rail service, reliability, and rates, particularly where they are served by only one carrier. Further consolidation threatens to exacerbate existing service challenges and further entrench the lack of competition that has left shippers with little leverage to negotiate fair rates or secure reliable service.
The Senators also raised concerns about threats Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena made earlier this year against shippers – including Wisconsin farmers, businesses, and manufacturers – who speak out against the merger. In a video Senator Baldwin helped make public, Vena told a room of rail shippers that he’ll probably raise rates on anyone who opposes the merger to “teach [them] a lesson.” The Senators urged the Surface Transportation Board to take Vena’s words seriously and consider whether such threats prevent shippers from raising legitimate concerns about this merger’s impact on already high costs and poor service.
“Given the extraordinary scale and potential consequences of this transaction, the applicants must demonstrate that the merger will enhance competition and deliver meaningful benefits to shippers and consumers—rather than simply promise greater efficiencies. We do not believe that the railroads have met that standard, and we believe further consolidation of the freight rail industry is not in the public interest. We urge the Board to reject the proposed UP-NS merger,” concluded the Senators.
For months, Senator Baldwin has been urging federal regulators to thoroughly scrutinize this merger’s impact on competition, shipping costs, and service reliability for Made in Wisconsin businesses who rely on freight rail:
- July 2025: Senators Baldwin and Marshall urged the Surface Transportation Board (STB) to closely examine the proposed merger’s impact on competition, costs, and reliability.
- November 2025: During a Senate Commerce Committee nomination hearing, Baldwin pressed STB member nominees Richard Kloster and Michelle Schultz on whether they would act independently of President Trump when making regulatory decisions.
- December 2025: Senator Baldwin called on the STB to reject the merger application filed by Union Pacific to acquire Norfolk Southern.
- June 2026: During a Senate Commerce Committee nomination hearing, Baldwin questioned STB nominee Karen Hedlund on CEO Jim Vena’s past comments threatening retaliation. She also asked for clarification if Union Pacific could disregard its burden to prove the merger satisfies the public interest statute.
- July 2026: Baldwin urged the Surface Transportation Board to take Union Pacific’s threat of retaliation against shippers who do not support its merger with Norfolk Southern seriously.
- November 2026: A video Senator Baldwin helped make public showed Union Pacific CEO Jim Vena threatening to raise rates on customers – including Wisconsin farmers, manufacturers, and businesses – who oppose the Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern megamerger, saying he’ll probably raise rates on shippers who oppose the merger to “teach [them] a lesson.”
A full version of this letter is available here and below.
Dear Chair Fuchs, Vice Chair Schultz, Member Hedlund, and Member Kloster,
We write today with serious concerns regarding the proposed merger of Union Pacific (UP) and Norfolk Southern (NS). If approved, this transaction would represent the most significant consolidation in the freight rail industry in decades and would reshape the U.S. freight rail network and supply chain. Specifically, we are concerned that a merger of this magnitude could increase costs, reduce transportation options for shippers, undermine reliable service, and further diminish competition in an already highly consolidated industry. Given these significant risks to rail shippers, consumers, and the broader U.S. economy, we urge the Board to reject the proposed merger.
Since the 1950s, the rail industry has consolidated from more than 100 Class I freight railroads to only six today. This consolidation has left many manufacturers, utility companies, agricultural producers, and small businesses with limited competitive options for moving their goods. In recent years, shippers across the country have raised concerns about rail service, reliability, and rates, particularly where they are served by only one carrier. Further consolidation threatens to exacerbate existing service challenges and further entrench the lack of competition that has left shippers with little leverage to negotiate fair rates or secure reliable service.
We are also deeply concerned by the recently released video of UP CEO Jim Vena’s remarks at the Southwest Association of Rail Shippers annual conference in March 2026. Mr. Vena suggested raising rates by an additional three to four percent on customers who opposed the merger to “teach [them] a lesson.” While UP has characterized these remarks as a joke, the company resisted public disclosure of the footage, including by appealing an administrative law judge’s order, prompting the Board to deny its appeal on November 4, 2026. The video is now public, and the Board should take Vena at his word that he plans to retaliate against shippers and consider whether shippers can meaningfully participate in the Board’s review process without fear of retaliation. The Board must be able to hear candidly from shippers to fully evaluate the potential impacts of this merger, particularly in an industry where many customers have limited competitive alternatives.
A merger of this magnitude could also trigger consolidation among the remaining Class I railroads. The Board recognized this concern when it adopted its major rail merger rules in 2001, establishing a heightened standard for major transactions and requiring applicants to demonstrate that a proposed transaction is consistent with the public interest and adequately addresses competitive harms. Those rules also require consideration of the potential downstream effects of further consolidation. We strongly urge the Board to apply these standards rigorously in its review of the proposed UP-NS merger.
The proposed UP-NS merger would further concentrate market power in an already consolidated industry, threatening to increase costs, undermine reliable service, and leave shippers with even fewer options. The recent concerns surrounding potential retaliation against shippers only underscore the risks associated with increased consolidation. Given the extraordinary scale and potential consequences of this transaction, the applicants must demonstrate that the merger will enhance competition and deliver meaningful benefits to shippers and consumers—rather than simply promise greater efficiencies. We do not believe that the railroads have met that standard, and we believe further consolidation of the freight rail industry is not in the public interest. We urge the Board to reject the proposed UP-NS merger.
NOTE: This press release was submitted to Urban Milwaukee and was not written by an Urban Milwaukee writer. While it is believed to be reliable, Urban Milwaukee does not guarantee its accuracy or completeness.
Mentioned in This Press Release
Recent Press Releases by U.S. Sen. Tammy Baldwin
Baldwin Demands Answers From Trump Admin on Root Cause of Nov. 13th Nationwide Ground Stop
Nov 17th, 2026 by U.S. Sen. Tammy BaldwinAbrupt ground stop disrupted more than 10,000 flights and affected an estimated 1.5 million passengers
Baldwin, Colleagues Urge FTC to Crack Down on Corporations Pocketing Consumers’ Tariff Refunds
Nov 13th, 2026 by U.S. Sen. Tammy BaldwinCorporations raised prices to cover President Trump’s tariffs, but now they are keeping billions in refunds while families get no money back
Baldwin Leads Colleagues in Introducing Bill to Lower Age of Medicare Eligibility to 50, Lower Health Care Costs
Nov 10th, 2026 by U.S. Sen. Tammy BaldwinMedicare at 50 Act would give more than 58 million Americans ages 50 to 64 another option for affordable health care












