Graham Kilmer
MKE County

Controversial Trail in Jackson Park Neighborhood Completed

Neighbors feared new bike trail would bring crime, drugs and prostitution to the park.

By - Nov 18th, 2026 01:54 pm

Road-to-trail conversion in the Kinnickinnic River Parkway. Photo taken Nov. 17, 2026 by Graham Kilmer.

Milwaukee County Parks recently finished constructing a trail in Jackson Park that some neighbors believed would invite crime and disorder to their quiet, leafy neighborhood and rob them of a roadway they liked.

Neighbors worried the multi-use trail would mean homeless camps popping up along the Kinnickinnic River Parkway and that it would create new opportunities for drug use and prostitution. The trail itself would be an obstruction to police response. Property values would tank. The whole neighborhood would go to pot.

In short order, residents organized a group called “Save Jackson Park Drive” to protect their homes and families from the dangerous effects of the planned bicycle and pedestrian trail. They wanted to preserve the road between their homes and the parkland, a road they viewed as intrinsic to the identity and “unique design of this beautiful neighborhood.”

In 2022, Parks proposed converting a section of W. Jackson Park Drive along the parkway to a multi-use trail. The department is responsible for maintaining more than 60 miles of roads and parkways across the county, and Jackson Park Drive is one of them. Roads and parking lots are expensive infrastructure to build and maintain. They consume a large chunk of the department’s annual budget. They have to be plowed and salted, and the heavy wear of vehicles requires frequent patching.

Jackson Park Drive had not been repaved in more than 40 years. The parks budget has essentially been frozen since the late 1980s, and inflationary cost increases have decimated the budget, leading to a shrinking workforce and contributing to a growing backlog of maintenance now estimated at approximately $500 million.

Converting parkways to trails meets a number of the department’s high-level policy priorities. It creates long-term financial savings in maintenance costs. It reduces the amount of paved surfaces in the system, which are sources of polluted stormwater runoff when it rains. It also adds a new recreational amenity that protects pedestrians and bicyclists from motor vehicle traffic. As the department devotes a greater share of its infrastructure spending to roads and parking lots, it has less funding for the recreational infrastructure park patrons enjoy, like playgrounds, athletic facilities and trails.

Over the past 12 months, Parks has converted four roadways to mixed-use trails, including in Jackson Park. In each case, the roads represented a redundant right of way for automobiles that could reach the same nearby destinations using municipal streets.

In the case of Jackson Park Drive, Parks proposed converting the road to a trail between S. 58th Street and S. 51st Street. The road curved along the Kinnickinnic River Parkway, past backyards. The road did not provide vehicle access to any of the homes between these blocks, though some homes did have an address on W. Jackson Park Drive.

But Parks faced stiff resistance from residents who didn’t want to lose the parkway, and fearmongering over what the trail might portend. The pushback proved too much for the local county supervisors whose districts overlapped the proposed trail project: Sup. Juan Miguel Martinez and Ald. Peter Burgelis, who was then a supervisor. They came out in opposition to the road-to-trail conversion and promoted a compromise solution, which would convert only a section of the roadway to a trail.

Parks mocked up designs and cost estimates for the various options. The compromise idea left two blocks between S. 51st and S. 53rd streets converted to a trail; the rest of the road would be reconstructed. Where the road remained, the new trail would run alongside it. It would cost $300,000 more to build.

The county board approved the compromise plan in 2024. Construction recently finished. On Tuesday, Parks held a ribbon-cutting for the new trail-road project. Dozens of neighbors attended. So did Martinez, Burgelis and Sup. Sky Capriolo, who was elected to Burgelis’ seat just a few weeks after the issue of the trail was laid to rest by the board.

At the intersection of W. Jackson Park Drive and S. 53rd Street, where the newly surfaced road meets the newly built trail, Capriolo said she was standing at “the corner of cooperation and patience.”

Cooperation was what they celebrated Tuesday. Parks Director Guy Smith said the project was a result of the department working with neighbors to find a solution and that, from what he’d heard, “it turned out better than people expected.” Martinez noted the project was “something that ended up working for all the residents.” 

“This was my first legislative problem where the goals of the neighborhood differed from the goals of the administration, and a lot of effort went into making sure that this project can align both with the neighborhood and with the long-term sustainability goals,” Burgelis said. “And what we have now is, I think, the best of both worlds, something better than either group could have imagined years back.”

Burgelis, who lives in the neighborhood, said he takes his dog for a walk on the trail every morning now. “I’ve seen more families, more strollers, more bikes,” he said. Capriolo, too, noted that even during the short celebration Tuesday afternoon, “we saw bikers go by, dog walkers, joggers.”

Martinez saw an example of why he got into public service in the first place.

“When I ran for county supervisor the first time, my number one goal was to beautify our parks,” he said. “Parks are what make a district live and breathe. Without a healthy park, a neighborhood cannot flourish.”

No one had much to say about the road, though, except Smith, who framed the reconstruction as “a bit of a road diet,” urban planning jargon for engineering projects designed to make roadways safer for all users. Most attention was paid to the new trail, lined with trees showing autumn colors. The crowd gathered only seemed to notice the road when they were hopping out of the way of cars trying to drive past.

If you think stories like this are important, become a member of Urban Milwaukee and help support real, independent journalism. Plus you get some cool added benefits.

Leave a Reply

You must be an Urban Milwaukee member to leave a comment. Membership, which includes a host of perks, including an ad-free website, tickets to marquee events like Summerfest, the Wisconsin State Fair and the Florentine Opera, a better photo browser and access to members-only, behind-the-scenes tours, starts at $9/month. Learn more.

Join now and cancel anytime.

If you are an existing member, sign-in to leave a comment.

Have questions? Need to report an error? Contact Us